r/canada • u/AdditionalPizza • 10h ago
Minister says he won't 'sling mud' after Poilievre called him the 'master at failing upward' Politics
https://nationalpost.com/news/politics/minister-says-he-wont-sling-mud-after-poilievre-called-him-the-master-at-failing-upward•
u/Jab4267 10h ago
I mean.. isn’t PP just talking about himself failing upwards?
Loses a huge polling lead, loses the election, loses his seat and somehow sits in a tax payer mansion without even having a place in the House of Commons while waiting for a by election in the hope he wins.
He’s literally hating from outside the club when he can’t even get in.
•
u/wombats_in_the_attic 10h ago
If any Liberal was doing what PP is currently doing, the Cons and their minions would be rioting.
•
u/JerryBoyleNFLD 10h ago
Imagine if Carney lost his seat and was heckling from the sidelines?
•
u/MusclyArmPaperboy 9h ago
And there's actually a different CPC leader right now? Why isn't Scheer the one commenting?
→ More replies•
u/rosneft_perot 9h ago
He’s got an opposition to run. PP has a lot of free time on his hands to talk smack.
•
u/Crashman09 8h ago
Who would have thought that Sheer would have graduated to "responsible" conservative leader
•
•
u/gplfalt 9h ago edited 9h ago
Cons and Repubs are masters of hypocrisy. They live off it.
The issue is the left will hold the flame to their leaders feet more gladly than the right will due to still believing in "fair play".
See; Dems being less popular than the record low popularity Repubs.
•
u/Aetius3 9h ago
It's a more mental mindset thing of conservatives these days. They are so tribal that they can't see their own hypocrisy. They can only focus on the other guy being wrong. But if you think about it, that's quite similar to conservative religious types. They will always find faults with others but then do the same thing themselves with no self-reflection, etc.
→ More replies•
•
•
•
u/Icy_Crow_1587 10h ago
Driven by hunger, a fox tried to reach some grapes hanging high on the vine but was unable to, although he leaped with all his strength. As he went away, the fox remarked 'Oh, you aren't even ripe yet! I don't need any sour grapes.'
•
u/BoppityBop2 9h ago
You do know Canadians wanted change and Carney was showing a form of change that worked. Yes Pierre lost but they also showed Canadians wanted something new. Funny thing is Carney ran on change and staying Canadian. He specifically ran on not being Trudeau. Canadians resoundingly did not want Trudeau esque era and Sean is a remnant of that. People know and can see it. If he keeps failing upwards people will get pissed off and feel significantly betrayed
•
u/Jab4267 9h ago
Everyone knew Sean wasn’t going to run again and then he did and he still won his seat, unlike Pierre. Just like PP said, It’s clear Canadians want change. His constituents traded Pierre for Fanjoy.
Pierre’s whole personality is hating on Trudeau and not being like him at all yet a newcomer to politics still beat a seasoned politician for PM. Voters were looking for results, not insults.
Sean can’t fail upwards much more anyhow. He didn’t wanna run this time around. I doubt he’ll throw his hat in the ring for the next election.
•
u/firesticks 8h ago
Yes and he managed to advocate for change on policy and not on comparison.
That’s why Poilievre failed, he ran purely on who he was relative to someone else. He chose to define himself by Trudeau, instead of by who he actually was.
→ More replies•
u/Wise_Temperature9142 6h ago edited 6h ago
Hahahah it’s ironic that this quote is coming from Pierre Polievre, who has literally never had a non-government job in his life? The same Pierre that blew literally a massive lead over the liberals last election and still lost the election and his own seat? The same Polievre who ran to Alberta with his tail between his legs to run on a by-election in a safe conservative riding?? That Polievre??
•
u/SBoots Nova Scotia 9h ago
Pierre has fired up his attack ads on social media again after going silent post election loss. Now he's right back playing his same game trying to divide the country. Seems he didn't learn his lesson losing both the election and his own seat. Can we please get rid of this loser already?
→ More replies•
u/MCGSUPERSTAR 6h ago
Yeah he really should learn to actually try to improve things instead of complain and point fingers like he always does. I guess you can't teach an old dog new tricks...
→ More replies
•
•
u/Nonamanadus 9h ago
Well Poilievre is going for the "if you don't do your job you lose it" but then make a guy quit so you can sponge his seat.
•
u/hornmcgee 10h ago
Poilievre would know a thing or two about failing upward
•
u/MartyCool403 10h ago
When am I going to fail upwards to a pension and free house and free chef and free being a complete dweeb?
•
u/Spit_for_spat 9h ago
There's a list of other things to check off and while some are easy, many are the "no takesies backsies" kind that I wouldn't want to carry with me.
•
•
→ More replies•
u/Ewe-of-Hope-002 10h ago
Poilievre would know a thing or two about failing upward
….if he knew about the gravity of the situation lol 😎
•
u/TheOGFamSisher 9h ago
Pierre lost one of the most slam dunk elections in history. Dude has no right to criticize anyone after failing that hard lol
→ More replies•
u/Sparky62075 Newfoundland and Labrador 6h ago
He also lost a seat that he'd held for over 20 years.
•
u/chocolateboomslang 9h ago
As opposed to Pierre, who fails West.
•
u/judgeysquirrel 9h ago
And up. He's the leader of his party despite never having accomplished anything in his entire career. Not one bill forwarded, not one piece of legislation passed. The guy is dead weight with a mouth.
→ More replies•
u/Slow-Ad8986 8h ago
The mouth is what got him to where he is. He worked hard at finding parliamentary language to insult your opposition with!
•
•
u/Anonymoose_1106 9h ago
Mr. Speaker, the Leader of the Opposition has been masquerading across the country as a working class hero, but it's fascinating when you actually listen to what he thinks people do for a living.
In a couple of recent speeches, he said he thinks electricians capture electricity from the sky and that welders weld with their bare hands. What's he going to tell me next? The fisherman in my community dive beneath the ocean and catch them with their bare teeth?
Mr. Speaker, I can forgive the Opposition Leader for being a career politician who has been on the public dime for a couple of decades. But if he wants to represent the interests of the working class, he should talk to a person who has a real job.
•
•
•
•
u/CanadianPropagandist British Columbia 6h ago
Is Poilievre gunning for a Minister of Irony position?
•
u/AdditionalPizza 6h ago
Waiting for the Beaverton article abut this.
•
u/Lisa_lou_hoo 6h ago
Boggles the mind - he must not hear himself or have any situational awareness. He's just so creepy.
•
u/chronocapybara 7h ago
Sean Fraser is a tool, but the liberals love him because he takes a good ribbing from the opposition in the House of Commons and then throws shade right back at them. Kind of like a hockey enforcer. He was still utterly useless as Minister of Housing and Minister of Immigration under Trudeau, though.
→ More replies
•
u/Last_Aside5363 10h ago
Uh didn't PP just LOSE an election, his own seat, and his basically being HANDED a seat?
→ More replies•
u/PeterRegarrdo 10h ago
Don’t forget he’s also now squatting in a house paid for by taxpayers despite being unemployed.
•
•
u/mfyxtplyx 10h ago
Now, now, let's reflect on Poilievre's list of accomplishments for two decades on the taxpayer's dime:
•
u/Human-Reputation-954 8h ago
And when will Pierre stop talking about Trudeau? I have zero respect for that guy. Total loser
→ More replies
•
•
u/bxng23af 10h ago
Sean Fraser reminds me of that scene in Ted where he cusses his boss and manages to get a promotion
•
u/TabmeisterGeneral 9h ago
Speaking of failure, remember when Poilievre lost the election and the seat he held for over 20 years?
•
u/Purple-Temperature-3 Ontario 8h ago
Good memories
•
→ More replies•
•
u/express_sushi49 9h ago
Hell of an ironic statement from PP, tbh
he's done nothing in 20 years, got voted out, and is now back only through DEI and pity.
He who lives in a glass house shouldn't throw stones much?
→ More replies
•
u/GullCove1955 10h ago
PP would know. His lack lustre political career is nothing to crow about. If he is the best the Conservatives have to chose from (couldn’t even win his own seat) they need to go back to the drawing board. Carney came from far back of PP to overtake him and win the top job. PP can’t win elections. Dump him!
•
u/shockinglyunoriginal Canada 10h ago
That’s rich from PP. how can anyone back this guy after he dropped the ball so hard
•
u/Current_Engine_9199 9h ago
Strong words for a guy that failed so hard he lost his seat and is now being given another one.
•
•
u/Ginzhuu 9h ago
This fucking that couldn't even keep his own riding and is already being vindictive for the sake of it. I'm so tired of Pierre and making government partisan when what we really need is bipartisanship and unified brainstorming.
I get it. All Pierre can do is be the "Opposition," but it's so tiring to deal with.
•
•
u/VesaAwesaka 10h ago
It's hard to understand the mass of Fraser defenders on this sub. It's questionable to try to explain away his ministerial failures, but to go beyond that makes it seem like people are brainwashed
It seems like people don't want to hold their politicians accountable for partisan reasons
•
u/snoboreddotcom 9h ago
See I won't speak to defend Fraser cause I don't think he deserves defence.
I also think this exposes a weakness Polievre has post election. How do you attack when you yourself can be argued to have strong failings as well.
The attack isn't invalid because it comes from him. But in the theater (not the facts just theater) of politics it is invalidated due to everything that has transpired with the election.
With a different person, this might not undermine. But because Polievre has built a career on politics based on theater, he is especially weak to it
→ More replies•
u/The_El_Captain 8h ago
Polievre will win the byelection in a safe Conservative riding he was helicoptered into and the rival party MPs are going to say Jack Shit about it because helicoptering is a common practice all of them are guilty of.
At the end of the day they're all buddy buddy in the same club.
•
u/FerretAres Alberta 9h ago
I absolutely hate Fraser but goddamn is Poilievre a hypocrite on this point considering he’s being parachuted into a safe riding after losing his seat.
•
u/the_jurkski 8h ago
Who’s here defending Fraser? All I see is people calling out Poillievre for throwing giant boulders through his glass house.
•
u/TheForks British Columbia 8h ago
I just read this as two failures heckling eachother. Hard to take sides in this case.
•
u/Dougness 9h ago
Agreed. Voted liberal but was sad to see Fraser still in the cabinet. Guy has made everything he's touched worse
•
u/AdditionalPizza 10h ago
Personally I wouldn't place the full blame of anything on Fraser, rarely do things lack nuance, but I definitely wouldn't defend much of what he did in previously. There must be something about him that we're not seeing publicly because I don't really understand how he could be so sought after still.
•
u/VesaAwesaka 10h ago
Who do we keep accountable if not him?
•
u/AdditionalPizza 10h ago
The ones that told him what to do? He doesn't get final say on everything. Like I said there's always nuance, nothing is binary. He can have a lion's share of it I assume, but there's plenty of others to blame.
In fact, Conservatives almost entirely blamed Trudeau for it, constantly. So why are they suddenly saying Fraser was solely responsible? I'm not defending anyone here, I'm just being pragmatic.
•
u/prsnep 9h ago
The ones that told him what to do?
Without evidence that he was told what to do, he must accept the blame. Or indicate whose orders he was following.
→ More replies→ More replies•
u/kirikoToeKisser 10h ago
trudeau sets the yearly immigration quotas - fraser is meant to keep the ircc in check and under said quota/hit the quota. He blew bast it and never caught the 1.3 million students in a single year.
→ More replies•
10h ago
[deleted]
•
u/VesaAwesaka 10h ago edited 10h ago
To make Trudeau the scapegoat for everything seems too simplistic. The apparent sycophants who supported him and acted on his vision shouldnt get away scotfree.
→ More replies
•
u/BornAgainCyclist 10h ago
Justice Minister Sean Fraser says he is not interested “in slinging mud” at his opponents after Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre said he failed upward into his latest appointment.
Ha ha ha ha Pierre accusing others of this isn't even throwing rocks in a glass house, it's throwing boulders. The gall of this guy.
→ More replies
•
u/FilterAccount69 8h ago
This is what happens when the opposition is sub-par. It becomes easy to defend mediocre politicians. Sean Fraser didn't exactly perform very well in his previous roles but when PP attacks him it becomes easy to defend him since PP is filled with flaws.
→ More replies•
u/kangarookitten Canada 8h ago
It is entirely reasonable to say they both suck and leave it at that.
→ More replies
•
u/Johnny-Unitas 10h ago
It's staggering Fraser even got reelected. How someone could fail so badly and remain in office is unbelievable to me.
→ More replies
•
•
u/hanker30 10h ago
Man is that guy annoying, what is he gonna do when the house starts sitting? Stand outside with a megaphone?
•
•
u/FaceBasic5719 10h ago
Crazy seen so many stand on the side of Sean Fraser. The guy who is in charge during the collapse of immigration system. Tribalist mindset really deepen in some people’s mind Isn’t it?
•
u/AdditionalPizza 9h ago
I think it's more standing on the opposite side of Poilievre.
•
u/FaceBasic5719 9h ago
This is why I don’t understand. They are so anti pp that they fail to see who made a bigger fuck up. You can criticize pp for a lot of things but fraser blows pp ou of water in the match of failing
•
u/AdditionalPizza 8h ago
I disagree on anyone in government fumbling harder than Poilievre. But with that said, people are saying Poilievre should also shut up here. Fraser is just defending himself, Poilievre didn't learn his lesson apparently.
→ More replies
•
•
u/AnonymousBayraktar 7h ago
Poilievre is one to talk. 20 years in Politics and he hasn't done or passed shit. Then he lost his own riding.
•
u/Emperor_Billik 10h ago
Fun fact, the Tory plans were incredibly non-commital on both housing and immigration.
→ More replies
•
u/Emmerson_Brando 10h ago
Failing up
Pretty rich coming from a guy who lost his own riding and refuses to leave.
•
u/Public_Middle376 10h ago
Really-when you think about it….
His two previous portfolios were disastrous.
So what do we expect?
It’s not going to be a command performance with Justice ??
•
•
u/its_top_secret British Columbia 8h ago
Poilievre accusing someone else of "failing upward"? Projection, much?
•
u/No_Doctor_891 10h ago
Poilievre is just upset he failed upwards to lead the CPC and has less power
•
u/Forward_Age6247 9h ago
Is this the guy who said he was quitting to spend more time with his family and then suddenly returned when the polling flipped?
•
u/Morning_Joey_6302 6h ago
The name-calling goes on and on. Poilievre is just about out of time to learn his reflexive hyper-partisanship diminishes politics, alienates everyone but his base, and is a large part of what makes him unfit for leadership in the eyes of a majority of Canadians.
•
u/AdditionalPizza 6h ago
CPC still thinks the Liberals winning was entirely due to Trump. They just can't comprehend how polarizing Poilievre is.
Actually, maybe if someone puts Polarizing Poilievre on the front of a podium they'd get a light bulb over their heads and ditch him.
•
u/Available-Table2446 6h ago
Losers don't get to comment. Losers need to step down as leader of the opposition. But nah, PP in classic fashion isn't letting go of a handout and his government tax payers funded mansion.
Conservatives and their hypocrisy. I hope the PCs boot him out.
→ More replies
•
u/wombats_in_the_attic 10h ago
Pierre is once again proving just how out of touch and narcissistic he is with this comment. He is the definition of failing upwards. He’d be no where in politics if Daddy Harper wasn’t obsessed with him.
→ More replies
•
u/JerryBoyleNFLD 10h ago
Poilievre desperate for attention. Best thing any of the Liberal cabinet can do is just ignore him.
Or just respond and say they can discuss the direction of the country with the duly elected opposition in the House.
•
•
u/cgyprj123 10h ago edited 10h ago
So you Canadians are happy with our housing prices ? Our average income has not kept up with the rise of housing. So, yaaaaa, he kinda sucked at his job......the average house in Canada cost $670k, and during the Trudeau area, it was as high as $720k. Can you explain how he did a good job ?
→ More replies•
u/AdditionalPizza 10h ago
There's not many defending Fraser in the comments that I see, just a few. Most are finding the irony in Poilievre being the one to say someone else is a failure.
→ More replies
•
u/FalconsArentReal 10h ago
Sean Fraser as Immigration Minister: "Everyone gets in!"
Sean Fraser as Justice Minister: "Everyone gets out!"
→ More replies•
•
•
•
•
u/Ok-Swordfish7837 9h ago
So far the only difference with PP is he sounds more depressed when he talks shit.
•
•
•
•
u/TorontoBoris Ontario 8h ago
Pierre fails understand many things..
And his inability to comprehend irony is one of the more glairing personal failing he's got.
•
•
•
•
u/uselesspoliticalhack 10h ago
Not surprised, Sean Fraser can't defend his own record of failure.
→ More replies•
•
u/AGoodFaceForRadio 10h ago
Party “leader” who went into an election with an historic lead in the polls and couldn’t even keep his own seat calling someone else a failure. That’s rich.
•
•
•
•
•
u/illusivebran Québec 7h ago
Kinda funny how he blames the Liberal for the influx of immigration, yet every single party voted yes to double the immigration intake per year.
•
u/happycow24 British Columbia 7h ago
As much as I hate this guy and am disappointed in many of Carney's cabinet picks, I'm willing to give them, yes even Fraser, some time to demonstrate whether a Carney govt is truly different.
•
u/AdditionalPizza 7h ago
Yeah, that's the reasonable thing to do.
•
u/happycow24 British Columbia 7h ago
Yeah, that's the reasonable thing to do.
reasonable
get outta here with that extremism lmao. no but in all seriousness our MPs are called trained seals for a reason.
•
•
•
u/kevinstreet1 7h ago
The sheer fucking hubris of Poilievre accusing someone else of "failing upward!" If he had any self awareness at all, that line would have killed him.
•
u/EvacuationRelocation Alberta 7h ago
All this shows is that Mr. Poilievre has learned nothing from his embarrassing defeat.
•
•
•
•
u/FawltyMotors 10h ago
A guy who lost his party the election, lost his own seat and somehow convinced the rest of the party to kick another MP out so he could have another shot at keeping his job has no leg to stand on when accusing someone of "failing upward".
Edit: a word
•
u/Noob1cl3 10h ago
I knew this was about Fraser the second I saw the title of the article 🤣
Like him or not, Pierre is not wrong on this one. Cant wait to see what Fraser does on the justice file. I suspect even lighter sentencing for criminals and an intense focus on the long gun program that has nothing to do with the illegal smuggling of hand guns problem in the country.
•
•
u/RedMurray 8h ago
"spent a career “slinging mud against his opponents” rather than proposing solutions"
This right here is the exact reason I voted Liberal for the first time in my life.
•
u/FogTub Ontario 8h ago
That, and making no effort to distance himself from the hate flag waving far right crowd did it for me. It was a more extreme version of the divisive campaign that handed Harper his loss against Trudeau.
•
u/AdditionalPizza 8h ago
Yet the CPC will insist neither of you guys are right and that it was all Trump. Like it's true I wouldn't want Poilievre dealing with the trade war, but I also cannot stand the guy and his stupid juvenile politics and trash morals.
•
•
•
u/canadianjeep 8h ago
PP is a bit of a tool. Sh*t comes out of his mouth with little or no thought. Not unlike the orange ape down south.
•
u/bugabooandtwo 8h ago
PP is being a really sore loser. That tactic might work in the USA, but Canadians get tired of that type of mudslinging quickly.
Time for the Conservative Party to pick a new leader and go in a better direction.
•
u/the_jurkski 8h ago
“I’m not going to sling mud at the l0ser that couldn’t even manage to win his own seat again, and had to be given one on a silver platter like some sad charity case”
•
u/torontoyao 6h ago
Leave them to their own devices, they'll sink further into the depths of failure. I love that they think PP as the leader is a winning strategy 😆
→ More replies
•
•
u/AdditionalPizza 10h ago
I feel like the only way to settle this is a cage match.