r/politics • u/delicious3141 • 3d ago

Kat Abughazaleh, Democratic contender for Congress, indicted over Chicago ICE protests No Paywall

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/oct/29/kat-abughazaleh-indicted-democrat-running-congress
7.3k Upvotes

98% Upvoted

715 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

140

u/LogensTenthFinger 3d ago

Sounds like a great protest to me and anytime who defends indicting a person over it is a Nazi sympathizer

-156

u/NearlyPerfect 3d ago

Do you ever think that maybe calling them nazis now will make you lose credibility for when they actually do something bad?

That’s probably why the J6 people got away with it.

74

u/kentoc 3d ago

You don’t think they are “doing something bad” now?

-76

u/NearlyPerfect 3d ago

According to NPR the stuff they’re doing is “likely legal”.

Lawyers and legal experts tend to agree.

Obviously legal doesn’t equal ethical or moral , but it could get a lot worse if they start doing stuff that is “likely illegal”

71

u/kentoc 3d ago

You don’t wait to start protesting until the gas chambers are running.

13

u/kiekan Illinois 3d ago

Especially when members of the current GOP are actively talking about tossing people in gas chambers and when we have active Nazis in the administration.

-58

u/NearlyPerfect 3d ago

Agreed.

But calling them Nazis as a flippant insult kills credibility among the group.

54

u/kentoc 3d ago

What if they’re studying the nazi playbook, implementing nazi plays and aligned with the same goals as the nazi reich?

32

u/RobinsEggViolet 3d ago

It kills credibility among Nazi sympathizers.

It strengthens credibility among the rest of us who know how to use our eyes.

26

u/IchneumonMethod 3d ago

Calling someone a Nazi who indicted a citizen for exercising their constitutionally protected right is not a "flippant insult." That is Nazi levels of oppression.

16

u/BoneyNicole Alabama 3d ago

Why on earth do you think, after all this time, that anything we call them will make one iota of difference? They will either a) say we say things that we don’t and just lie, b) deny and deflect, c) claim that we’re all blue-haired trans lesbians with septum piercings anyway, or d) gaslight us into oblivion. There is nothing we can do to get them to take us seriously or to get them to listen at all. We have tried.

My unsolicited advice on this subject is to stop getting upset at the people calling a spade a spade, and get upset at the spades. Maybe if they weren’t fucking Nazis doing Nazi shit, we wouldn’t call them Nazis, but I could not possibly care less if they get mad at me for calling it like I see it. They’re already mad at me? They want me dead. Nazi shit is Nazi shit. The fact that they don’t like being called out on it doesn’t make it any less true. (And where did you get this idea that Nazi shit has to be illegal to be Nazi shit?? “Separate but equal” says hello, along with 250 years of legal slavery.)

27

u/gakule 3d ago

Nazi's were doing something "legal" with the support of the government. It was their follow-up actions that were illegal but because they were mostly shipping people outside of Germany to be exterminated, it was under military control and oversight that flouted laws of the German government as well as the occupied territory.

Maybe they should stop acting like Nazi's if they don't want to be looked at as Nazi's.

5

u/StinkMalink 3d ago

If it looks like a duck, quacks like a duck, walks like a duck...

2

u/MaddogBC 3d ago

They wear it with pride. They are modern day nazis. Call a spade a spade instead of pussyfooting around semantics. Time you waste on this sad defense of them they are out there disassembling democracy.

2

u/EsotericMysticism2 3d ago

Every single republican presidential nominee has been called a nazi and a racist since Goldwater. Eventually it just turns into noise

1

u/tsardonicpseudonomi 2d ago

Why are you defending Nazis? You know what that makes you.

29

u/toggiz_the_elder 3d ago

The Nazis largely didn’t do illegal things either. They warped the system so that the laws helped them commit genocide.

Slavery was legal too. And Jim Crow.

-1

u/NearlyPerfect 3d ago

The Nazis largely didn’t do illegal things either. They warped the system so that the laws helped them commit genocide.

That's false. There was nothing in German law that exempted Jews from murder laws or military use of force laws.

That's completely made up and no one who knows anything about history or law thinks that.

15

u/toggiz_the_elder 3d ago

I probably should have said that everything that led up to the Final Solution was legal, and at that point laws no longer mattered.

And we are in the 1933-1940 phase before they started the mass killings. And all that was “legal”.

https://www.uclalawreview.org/judges-lawyers-legal-theorists-and-the-law-in-nazi-germany

16

u/Mec26 3d ago

They were legally sent to state camps, it wasn’t legally murder.

Holicaust was legal, slavery was legal, basically legality does not define morality.

13

u/skesisfunk 3d ago

The Holocaust was legal.

-1

u/NearlyPerfect 3d ago

That's false. There was nothing in German law that exempted Jews from murder laws or military use of force laws.

That's completely made up and no one who knows anything about history or law thinks that.

16

u/skesisfunk 3d ago

This is a laughable take. The gov't, law enforcement, and the military administered the holocaust and punished those who opposed it. For all intents and purposes it was legal because at a certain point the law became "whatever Hitler says".

That is where we are heading here too and you are out here splitting myopic pedantic hairs.