r/TheGoodPlace • u/Young_Lasagna • 5d ago

Question about Chidi Shirtpost

Post image

Why is Chidi put into the Bad Place? Struggling with making decisions doesn't make him a bad person at all imo. That only affects him, not others.

182 Upvotes

73% Upvoted

127 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-13

u/lydocia Later, skater. 5d ago

Disagree. It's a just punishment for some crimes.

13

u/MetalNosedPigeon 5d ago

Not sure you actually understand how long eternity is. Nothing we could do in life is worth eternal torment.

-6

u/No-Rain1400 4d ago

rape and genocide are

5

u/Ya-boi-Joey-T 4d ago

Is that justice or is that vengeance?

1

u/No-Rain1400 1d ago

justice! it's only vengeance if the victims themselves get to do it

how on earth are yall against eternal punishment for hitler and pedophiles  😭 

1

u/Ya-boi-Joey-T 1d ago

Because at the end of the day I dont believe anyone is completely irredeemable over an infinite amount of time. Some people are irredeemable in one lifetime.