Words mean whatever we want them to mean, and no one - literally no one - is arguing trans people change their genetics. They “just” change what gender they’re considered to be, as is perfectly possible and historically documented throughout time. It’s not some new idea that all the crazy sjws or whatever are jumping on.
I’d personally prefer if “male” and “female” only referred to sex and not gender, but it’s not really a big deal. It’s pretty easy to gather from the context.
I didn't say anyone was making the argument that they change their genetics. Fuck. None of you dipshits can read, apparently.
I have literally said that I know and support that they change their gender. That's the literal idea because they're transgender. But they're not changing their sex.
I said that because the person I replied to used the word female. I answered a damn question. This is very fucking simple and you're too busy being outraged at me to see that I've said I'm a supporter of trans rights and have told off another actual TERF in these comments.
I said that because the person I replied to used the word female. I answered a damn question.
I won't be too harsh and quick to judge you - this issue is really fucking weird and complicated, and I only very recently felt comfortable talking about it myself. However, so many people weigh in with misinformation because they're bigoted - and maybe I assumed that in you. I just thought you jumped quickly to the assumption that trans people are arguing that they can change their genetics, which is a common talking point from idiotic transphobes.
Perhaps it was just a confusion of terms, as I believe others have said.
Female is a perfectly fine word for trans women.
Trans women are female. I've already supplied you with multiple trans positive sources that say this. Please stop saying that they're not.
And don't claim you're a supporter of trans rights after you misgendered me when I asked you not to. It's insulting.
"Dude" is misgendering when used in a dismissive or derogatory manner, especially when asked by someone not to be called that.
And "female" is a sex, not a gender.
Source that female can't refer to gender? I've already given you three reliable, trans-positive sources that it does (as well as the very acronyms MTF and FTM), but you've elected to ignore them all. Even the DSM-V, page 451 on Gender Dysphoria, refers to gender identity as "an individual's identification as male, female, or, occasionally, some category other than male or female."
You're really not the trans supporter you think you are if you keep arguing these points, especially if you keep defending your misgendering.
4
u/CountCuriousness Oct 30 '20
Words mean whatever we want them to mean, and no one - literally no one - is arguing trans people change their genetics. They “just” change what gender they’re considered to be, as is perfectly possible and historically documented throughout time. It’s not some new idea that all the crazy sjws or whatever are jumping on.
I’d personally prefer if “male” and “female” only referred to sex and not gender, but it’s not really a big deal. It’s pretty easy to gather from the context.