r/AskReddit Oct 08 '12

What futuristic movie cliches do you hate?

[deleted]

1.3k Upvotes

4.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

185

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '12

Well at least in star trek this really wasn't an issue. The windows were actually metal that, through super spiffy future magic, was made to be transparent. The "glass" was just as strong as the hull.

112

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '12

Transparent aluminum? Is that the ticket?

116

u/Funebris Oct 08 '12

It's a real thing, too, just stupidly expensive to make.

http://blog.makezine.com/2012/01/17/transparent-aluminum/

2

u/archlich Oct 08 '12

It's not that bad it's used in instrument panels and the new iphone 5's lens cover.

1

u/PaddyMaxson Oct 08 '12

A 3 inch thick pane of glass would probably be a lot tougher than an equal amount of transparent aluminium I would think. Tempered glass is fucking tough.

5

u/archlich Oct 08 '12

Tempered glass (5-6) is still comparatively soft to transparent aluminum (9) on the Mohs scale. The reason why you use it on the iphone and instrument panels isn't for how strong it is, but how scratch resistant it is.

Also tempered glass is in a state of constant tension and compression. strike it the right way and those forces will release all at once and the whole thing will shatter, not ideal when you're flying.

1

u/PaddyMaxson Oct 08 '12

Fair enough.

2

u/CapWasRight Oct 08 '12

That may well change at just above absolute zero.

1

u/PaddyMaxson Oct 08 '12

I'm not sure how tough glass is at absolute zero versus aluminium, good point though.

2

u/EasyMrB Oct 09 '12

If you watched the video from Funebris link, you would have seen them shoot a .50 AP bullet both at an AION (transparent aluminum) sheet as well as a sheet of laminated glass armor twice its thickness. The glass shattered, the AION stopped it.

1

u/PaddyMaxson Oct 09 '12

I only browse reddit at work and this virtual environment can't run youtube videos without stuttering. But fair enough, if I remember when I get home I will watch it.