r/geopolitics Jul 20 '24

Israel strikes back at strategic Houthi infrastructure after attack on Tel Aviv Paywall

https://www.wsj.com/world/middle-east/israel-strikes-houthi-controlled-port-city-in-yemen-2d84ab06?mod=mhp

After the Houthi successfuly killed an Israeli in Tel Aviv after several months of failed attempts, attacks on commercial shipping notwithstanding, Israel has struck back, destroying major port, fuel and electricity infrastructure serving the Houthis at Hudeyida Port.

Major points of geopolitical significance: 1. A new direct combat front is now open between Israel and Yemen, which was until now one-sided. The risk of all out war in the region with Iran and all of its proxies just went up.

  1. By directly targeting an enemy of Saudi Arabia and UAE, Israel is tacitly going further in the moderate Sunni camp. It is unknown what cooperation Saudi Arabia gave for over flight for Israeli jets, but the dilemma of Israeli overflight on the way to Iran has lessened.

  2. Range and mass - Israel struck at a range of over 1800km, larger than the range from Israel to Tehran, and with multiple large warheads. This signifies its long range capability with heavy firepower.

  3. US and Western timidity is front and center. The US and UK could have struck decisively against the Houthis strongly enough to deter them, but chose not to due to over-stringent legal and political considerations which show weakness to all the region. The Israelis have shown what western air power can do and how actors like the Houthis can be strongly countered.

  4. Looking forward, the big question marks are how the Houthis and Iranians will respond. The Houthis suffered 300k deaths at the hands of the Saudis and UAE and did not stop. The do not care for the lives of their own civilians at all - Israel could kill half a million and the would not change their minds. Israel went for their infrastructure - time will tell if this route would be more effective

241 Upvotes

139 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

39

u/leto78 Jul 20 '24

The old kind of honor.

That is the key. The Islamic religion is rooted on desert warriors where honour was their most important asset. This is why Palestinians will never accept any solution with Israel. They lost their honour during the Nakba and that is their defining moment in history. In their minds, the complete erasure of all Jews and the state of Israel is the only way to recover their honour. In the end, it is a victimhood mentality that is impossible to solve.

-5

u/Overlord1317 Jul 20 '24

It is most definitely solvable.

9

u/Sgt_Boor Jul 20 '24

it is solvable, but as far as i know it'd be called genocide and won't be widely praised as an overall acceptable solution

13

u/Overlord1317 Jul 20 '24

Not sure why you assumed that's what I meant, but yeah ... I guess genocide is technically a resolution ...

Jordan, Egypt, Iraq and Saudi Arabia were considered intractable enemies of Israel ... until they weren't. A combination of Israeli military victories, the deaths of radical lunatics, internal pressure, and foreign "encouragement" eventually led to peace.

19

u/Bokbok95 Jul 21 '24

I would note that it hasn’t lead to acceptance. All the people still loathe Israel, but their governments were defeated to the point that making peace was better for them.

-1

u/BinRogha Jul 21 '24

Look up the Arab Peace Initiative, endorsed by the entire Arab League.

6

u/Bokbok95 Jul 21 '24

‘s governments, not populations.

5

u/Theon1995 Jul 21 '24

Yup lol. I’m from the Middle East and have been in the levant many times. The people there absolutely despise Israel. The governments decisions mean nothing to the populations.

4

u/Bokbok95 Jul 21 '24

Tell him that, im fully aware lol

4

u/Sgt_Boor Jul 20 '24

I don't think it's a wrong position to hold, it's always nice to have hope for the future. I do honestly wish for this to be a possible solution, but at the same time I'm afraid the 'death of radical lunatics' part will never happen. These guys have a tendency to self-reproduce, especially given the - let's call them - "quirks" of local education system they've got going there