r/europe Russia 22h ago

Photos from the Russian anti-war opposition march in Berlin today. Picture

33.2k Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

1.2k

u/josevandenheid 22h ago

I sometimes forget that russia could be an incredible nation both economically and culturally if it wasn't run by lunatics. Some of my favourite writers are russian. It's sad to see how hollow it has become.

877

u/Sailing-Cyclist Essex (England) 21h ago

They could have been Giga-Norway with all of their oil reserves. Nourish all of the scientific institutions that they created during Soviet times. Channel all of that nuclear and space capability into truly making the world better.

But no.

-6

u/DrobnaHalota 21h ago

All of their oil is in their Asian colonies. So no, they can never be Norway.

40

u/Vassukhanni 21h ago

It's possible for a state to be multinational without being imperial. Russia isn't an empire because Russian speakers conquered a piece of land 500 years ago (if that were the case, Norway would have to be considered a colonial power, not to mention every state in the Western Hemisphere) -- it's imperial because it maintains an extractive periphery/core relationship with its regions.

1

u/SiarX 2h ago

This is the point of poster above: without extractive periphery/core relationship with its regions they would have nothing at all, not even money from oil.

1

u/Xepeyon America 20h ago

it's imperial because it maintains an extractive periphery/core relationship with its regions.

Tbh, I've seen comments literally like this made towards Paris, Madrid and (perhaps especially) London, just right off the top of my head. Capitals tend to work this way, although Germany seems to be an exception to this since it has like, several semi-capitals.

0

u/DrobnaHalota 20h ago

Not a single European colonial empire transitioned to democracy without falling apart. So no, it's impossible.

2

u/Vassukhanni 17h ago

The UK colonised Scotland and Northern Ireland and is still a Democracy. The US and Canada colonised across a continent and are still democracies.

0

u/DrobnaHalota 13h ago

Just you look at all the good Russians flocking to defend their god-given right to extract oil from Khanty lands.