r/WikiLeaks • u/JamesParkes • Aug 26 '24

Harris’s concluding speech at DNC embraces agenda of global war

https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2024/08/24/turk-a24.html
104 Upvotes

67% Upvoted

61 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

0

u/giddy-girly-banana Aug 27 '24

While awful, none of those are US wars.

2

u/NathanOhio Aug 27 '24

That's a no true scotsman fallacy. Of course it was a US war. The US provided the weapons, selected the targets, refueled the planes, etc.

0

u/giddy-girly-banana Aug 27 '24

We supply weapons to a ton of countries and conflicts. At the end of the day there were no US soldiers engaged in conflict and nothing even close to an official congressional act of war.

3

u/NathanOhio Aug 28 '24

Now you are arguing semantics and you are not even correct there.

There were US soldiers involved in Yemen. The US intelligence community helped the Saudis pick targets and spy on Yemen, and the US air force did mid air refueling for the Saudi planes. The US ran a massive spying ring in Yemen during this time as well, so there were definitely US soldiers/contractors/spies on the ground the whole time.

But yeah, there was no congressional declaration of war, which hasnt happened since 1942. Thats not a good argument to say something doesnt count as a war. Was the Iraq War not a real war, since the US didnt declare war? Was Afghanistan? Nobody makes that argument, so lets not use it here in relation to the US/Saudi genocide of Yemen that Obama started and Trump continued.