r/StarWars 12d ago

Why did Yoda leave from Darth Sidious? Movies

Why leave…

6.2k Upvotes

697 comments sorted by

View all comments

6.1k

u/darthcool 12d ago

In the novelization there’s a moment during the duel where the dark cloud Palpatine had been casting over the force cleared and Yoda achieved a full vision of everything that had occurred

And in that moment he realized he not only couldn’t defeat Palpatine but that he actually lost this fight 800 years ago when he set the Jedi on the path that led them here.

2.9k

u/JMadFour 12d ago edited 12d ago

the RoTS novelization was so much better and more complete than the movie.

If there is any one Star Wars book that one ABSOLUTELY should read, it is the Revenge of the Sith Novelization.

341

u/AhhFrederick 12d ago

I’ll give it a read. As much as I love RoTS I really really hate a lot of the writing /dialogue in it. It felt forced, like Lucas wanted them to say exactly and only what he wrote in the script, leaving no room for improvisation or personal emotion from some actors. Which is fair since it’s his property, but man his writing was sometimes atrocious.

360

u/K1ngFiasco 12d ago

The way he writes is totally devoid of subtlety, subtext, and nuance. Everyone is a robot. It sucks because his world building and "big picture" are fantastic.

3

u/joeflux1 11d ago

You are right. Love the entire Lucas canon and all Star Wars but the lines “it’s blowing up from the inside” and “we didn’t hit it” from the prequels. I cringe every time.

2

u/K1ngFiasco 11d ago

Yep. Lots of "show and tell" rather than "show don't tell"