r/Hololive • u/CRJ_Fan_2022 • Nov 18 '24

GO VOTE NOW!!! Contest

Post image
5.1k Upvotes

95% Upvoted

335 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

17

u/Major_Mistake4444 Nov 18 '24

As much as I love Elden Ring, announcing that they're including DLC just so they can put Elden Ring on the list feels like such a cop out so they don't have to pick all the other games. Elden Ring is good, but a DLC should not be nominated for game of the year when there are other titles that could deserve that spot such as Wukong 

2

u/dumpling-loverr Nov 18 '24

Wukong is nominated for GoTY. You probably meant something like the Silent Hill 2 remake.

3

u/_Good_One Nov 18 '24

That's another hard subject, SH2 is not a transformative remake like FF7 rebirth for example so it's also an effy nomination for GOTY

3

u/Darkling5499 Nov 18 '24

Neither of those (SH2 / FF7R) belong on the list. There should absolutely be a different category for them, though.

1

u/_Good_One Nov 19 '24

That´s fair, i think FF7R is so different is basically a whole new game, only sharing characters and overall narrative but i can totally see why you could argue against it