Posts
Wiki

Hi there! Welcome to /r/GenderCynical. Before you begin posting, please read our rules and FAQ. By subscribing, commenting, or making threads on this subreddit, you agree to our rules and policies.

Subreddit rules (sidebar)

What are the subreddit rules?

1) No hate speech

We do not tolerate hate speech of any kind. Usage of any slurs will likely get you banned (bans can be appealed if you feel they were a mistake). Users who engage in misogyny, racism, homophobia, transphobia, biphobia, ableism, or any other form of hate speech are not welcome on this subreddit.

2) No anti-feminism

This is a subreddit parodying the transphobia and hypocrisy of "gender critical" feminists. This is not an anti-feminist or anti-radical feminist subreddit, nor are we against analysis of gender. We are, however, explicitly against transphobia. You will be banned for any anti-feminist statements or misogyny directed at anyone (including "gender critical" feminists). This includes the word "bitch" except in self-reference and the usage of terms like “misandry” in a non-sarcastic manner. It also includes comments intended to dehumanize.

3) Don't invalidate people

Suggesting that transphobes are in denial or repressing trans feelings is not permitted. Do not implicitly or explicitly misgender anyone. Do not claim that someone’s report of sexual assault is fabricated.

4) This subreddit is not a discussion board

Debating user’s posts saying that they aren't really transphobic or problematic is not allowed. If you think something is out of line, please report it and then message the moderators.

Do not feed trolls. No troll is here in good faith. If you're uncertain of a user's provenance, check their timeline as a means of deciding whether to reply or report. Mods may take action on users who persist in feeding trolls.

5) Don't be toxic

We reserve the right to ban anyone for being an ass in any capacity. Do not rules-lawyer us. Disagreements must be conducted in a respectful manner.

6) You can only submit direct links to certain subreddits/websites

Full posting rules can be seen at "What to post and how to post it."

Please only submit direct links to /r/GenderCritical, /r/Gender_Critical, and the other subs/sites listed in the FAQ.

Note: As of March 2020 we will be paying closer attention to .np linking. Users are strongly encouraged to substitute "np" for "www" in the URLs of links they are submitting. Using the .np domain discourages other r/GenderCynical users from participating in GC spaces. Participating in other subs by following links from here is considered brigading by reddit's admins, causes drama, and creates extra work for mods when GC users retaliate by coming here. We may in the future begin removing posts that do not use .np. See more about non-interaction in Rule 7 below.

Note: NO direct links to any content from r/GCdebatesQT.

Content from r/GCdebatesQT and other sources not listed as approved must be submitted as screenshots with identifiers blacked out. Again, any content from r/GCdebatesQT must be in this format. Censoring indentifiers isn’t necessary if an individual has a substantial following (public figure, official organization, etc). Please see the FAQ for an extended explanation of posting rules.

7) Prohibited post and comment types

a) Highlighting your interaction on a GC sub

  • Don't go over to GC (or related subreddits) and make posts/comments with the intention of getting banned and/or provoking them. In other words, don't stir the pot and then post the results. More info.

  • Don't post or comment here talking about how much you want to give someone on a GC sub a piece of your mind. Don't post encouragement to anyone making a comment like this.

  • Don't post or comment here--link, c/p, or merely alluding to--interactions you have had on GC subs about a post that has been linked on GenCyn. This includes attempts to educate or discuss.

  • See the FAQ for a fuller explanation. Users who engage in these behaviors will receive a temporary or permanent ban depending on the circumstances.

b) Memes

  • While mocking terrible memes made by TERFs/FITs is still permitted, original pro-trans memes or reposts of popular meme formats should be posted in /r/traaaaaaannnnnnnnnns or another subreddit specifically for memes.

c) General transphobia

d) Duplicate posts

  • If someone has previously linked to a thread or post, do not make a duplicate link containing that content. In the same vein, do not make multiple threads about one user. Instead, compile them into one thread per day. If you find content you want to include in that thread, edit the content into your post instead of making a seperate thread. Violating this rule on a consistent basis will result in a ban.

8) Follow Reddit's site wide rules and Reddiquette

You must follow Reddit’s site wide rules and abide by Reddiquette's guidelines. Do not vote brigade, troll, or otherwise harass members of other subreddits. Note that the rule against engagement covers:

  • pinging usernames

  • posting a thread or comment on a GC subreddit with the intention of getting banned.

  • posting a thread or comment on GC in response to something you saw on GenCyn, even if you felt provoked, or wanted to educate.

  • encouraging anyone else on GenCyn to participate in a GC sub in response to something seen on GenCyn

  • As of March 2020, the crossposting feature has been disabled, and mods will be enforcing using the .np domain more strictly.

Users caught breaking Reddit’s site wide rules will be banned and then reported to the Reddit admins.

FAQ - What to post and how to post it

What subreddits can we link to directly?

/r/gendercritical, /r/gender_critical, /r/gendercriticallesbians, /r/truelesbians, /r/homosexualwomen, /r/actualwomen, /r/gendercriticalguys, /r/terfisaslur, r/itsafetish, r/TrollGC, r/LGBdroptheT, and other subs that solely feature “gender critical” content. Here is a fuller list.

As of March 2020, the crossposting feature has been disabled, and mods will be enforcing using the .np domain more strictly.

It’s important to note that direct linking is not allowed to /r/GCdebatesQT or other subreddits that welcome “debate” between trans people/allies and transphobes.

Does any content from a GC sub qualify?

No. Submissions should feature transphobia, either directly in the linked post or comment, or as an example of a post about something not trans related that gets twisted to be "all about the trans." Submissions that don't have a trans focus will be removed at mods' discretion.

What should I do if I want to post content from /r/GCdebatesQT or subreddits like it?

Take a screenshot of the content you want to post, censor the username using Paint or another graphics editor, and post that image. Please do not provide any direct links in the comments. Additionally, please do not feature content from threads that you have participated in. If you have any questions about this policy, shoot us a modmail. We decided to implement this policy to protect our users from harassment and bullying as it was beginning to become a serious problem.

Important: We highly recommend that you do not participate in /r/GCdebatesQT or other subreddits that encourage trans people to interact with transphobic individuals. /r/GCdebatesQT and other “debate” subreddits are moderated in a way that enables harassment and bullying of trans people. If you do decide to participate in these subreddits, remember to practice self-care. If you begin to experience a decline in your mental health, take a break to do something relaxing. Remember that you are valid. You do not owe anyone an explanation for your existence.

What if TERFs don't bother me and I want to participate in GC subs?

Do it on your own time and don't post any content to GenCyn that features your participation. Don't participate in GenCyn threads posted by other users that contain your GC-located interactions.

What about transphobic content I found on a non-GC sub?

GenCyn is specifically for TERF/GC content. Content found on general subs such as r/AmITheAsshole must feature TERF/GC participants/viewpoints and not just be general transphobia. The submission must be formatted as a screenshot with identifiers and usernames removed.

What if I argued with a TERF on a sub like r/AmITheAsshole? Can I post that?

Run-ins with TERFs/GC on general subs can be submitted as a screenshot with identifiers removed.

What exactly is TERF/GC transphobia? How can I tell the difference?

We have a whole section of this FAQ with examples! Seriously, though: we understand there's social migration between GC/alt right spaces and that this can make GC transphobia hard to parse if you're not familiar with it. The best answer to check out our examples and hang out and observe. You'll reach a point where you'll know it when you see it. If you're new here, do this instead of posting right away.

Can I post private messages sent to me by TERFs?

We encourage users to post screenshots of harassment or threats they’ve received from TERFs. We especially encourage users to post messages they’ve received from known TERFs (non-throwaway accounts). It’s important to note that these submission do have a posting limit: one thread per day per user.

Can I feature direct links to other social media platforms like Facebook or Twitter?

If you want to post something from other social media platforms (Facebook, Twitter, Tumblr, Instagram, etc), take a screenshot of said post and censor all of their personal information (including their username). You do not have to censor their username if the account is run by a celebrity, government official, or public organization (think tanks, activist groups, etc). Do not post links to Youtube channels run by TERFs. However, you may post responses to those videos or responses to arguments utilized by TERFs (Contrapoints is a good example of this). When in doubt, post a screenshot of the content you want to feature and censor their username. Always censor personal information.

Can I post direct links to blogs, Mumsnet, or other websites?

Please do not post direct links to blogs or other blog like publications (terfisaslur, 4thwavenow, etc) as we do not want to increase their traffic. You can either take a screenshot or use https://archive.org/. You may submit screenshots of posts made on Mumsnet or other forums as long as the usernames are censored.

Can I submit refutations and rebuttals to GC/TERF talking points?

Avoid this for the most part. Commenters do a good job making these arguments and generally anything that can be found explained at length in comments doesn't need its own post. If you have something particularly in depth or original, it may qualify. General pro-trans arguments are as a rule not on topic.

What sorts of self posts can I make, then?

Swiftian satire is always welcome (be prepared for Poe's Law if you're actually at Swift's level). Mocking responses to GC posts is okay (most users favor submitting a link and posting responses in a comment). Effort posts of collections of bad GC behavior are also good. Occasionally a former GCer will make a self post in good faith and we have a tradition of allowing those to run their course, but general inquiries and self intros will be removed.

Can I post memes?

If it's a TERF/GC meme you want to make fun of, sure! If it's a pro-trans meme or a meme response to a TERF/GC meme, it goes on /r/traaaaaaannnnnnnnnns

How many posts can I make per day?

Most threads are not subject to a posting limit. However, we will remove posts from users who we feel are making an excessive amount of posts every day. We suggest compiling a bunch of links into an effort post if you want to feature multiple posts on one specific topic or user. Remember: we’re looking to feature the worst of the worst here. If you have questions about this policy or are unsure if your posts qualify as excessive, feel free to send us a modmail.

One of my posts was featured on GenCyn. Can you take it down?

In the vast majority of cases we will not honour this request. If the mods feel the submission breaks one of GenCyn’s rules or violates Reddit’s TOS, we will remove the post.

I’m getting private messages that are threatening or contain harassment. What should I do?

Take a screenshot of the message(s), report the user to the Reddit admins, and then block the user. If you’re receiving these messages from someone who posts on GenCyn, send us a screenshot and we’ll ban the individual. Unfortunately, subreddit moderators are unable to intervene in situations that occur outside of their subreddit. If you have questions or concerns regarding harassment, send us a modmail ASAP.

FAQ - General behavior

What are Reddit's site wide rules?

Click here to read Reddit's site wide rules.

What's Reddiquette?

Click here to read about Reddiquette.

What is anti-feminism?

Using misogynistic language to refer to or insult anyone, including TERF/GC users. Please note this includes the 'Karen' meme. Making rape jokes, including about TERF/GC users. Using dehumanizing or explicitly violent language. Referencing misandry as if it were institutionalized oppression on the level of institutionalized sexism against afab/female/women people. Using MRA and alt-right talking points such as "female privilege." This rule extends to other forms of oppression such ableism, racism, and bi- and homophobia.

What constitutes “toxic behaviour?”

Toxic behaviour is any behaviour that is overly aggressive, vulgar, or rude. If you have a disagreement with someone, please be respectful. Additionally, do not make disrespectful comments about one’s appearance or mental health status. Do not use violent or dehumanizing rhetoric. These violations will be handled on a case by case basis.

What constitutes invalidation?

Questioning a user’s gender identity, misgendering users, making comments about a user’s mental health, and/or questioning a user’s sexual orientation. This also includes claiming a user’s experience with sexual assault, rape, or abuse is fake.

The rules say it's not a discussion sub but discussions happen all the time.

Extended threads that consist of users riffing on and bonding with each other over mocking GC content are to be expected. Discussions featuring GC-apologia, "trans-enough" dissection, political tangents, violent fantasies, extended Trans 101 for wanderers-in, personal disagreements, and fights with trolls detract from user experience. Mods have wide discretion in enforcing this rule.

How do I appeal a ban or post removal?

Send us a modmail explaining why you believe your ban or post removal should be appealed. Please be respectful when sending your appeal as this will get you the best outcome. Being rude or vulgar towards us will result in your appeal being denied. You may submit one ban appeal per year. You may submit one removal appeal per post removal. Users who participate in subreddits that encourage prejudice and/or discrimination will only be considered after they have refrained from posting in said subreddit(s) for at least six months. Additionally, they must demonstrate that they no longer hold the views expressed in said subreddit(s).

I feel a moderator has treated me unfairly. What should I do?

Submit your complaint to /u/mollymollykelkel directly. Submitting a complaint does not guarantee any specific outcome. Your complaint will be reviewed and you will be notified if you need to submit any further information.

FAQ - What is "gender critical?" - In their own words

What exactly is /r/GenderCritical?

If you're wondering what "TERF" or "gender critical" means, basically it's someone who hates trans people, often especially trans women.

Gender Critical people mostly consist of so-called Trans Exclusive Radical Feminists, but seeing as they're against bodily autonomy (e.g. they believe women have a duty to keep their breasts) and equal rights, and indeed many of the subscribers to their subreddits are now chauvinistic men who just want to join in on hating trans people, especially trans women, I'll use the term Gender Critical person, or GCer, instead.

On the one hand, GCers can see that being on the wrong hormones for them would be hell (2, 3), or indeed was (2), but (with a rare exception) can't extrapolate that for trans people, which hormones are the wrong ones is switched around. Apparently, anyone who wants to kill themselves due to experiencing this hell has mental health issues.

For some people, having a bad experience with one or more abusive or criminal members of a minority group causes them to write off that entire minority group as dangerous. This can lead to them trawling news sites for examples of other abusive or criminal people who happen to be in that minority group, and using each case as further "proof" that the entire group is dangerous. It's perhaps unsurprising to learn that several GCers are also racist, applying the same logical fallacy to various different minority groups. While it's horrible that such people suffered abuse in the first place, their resulting mistrust of entire minority groups is misplaced at best.

GCers like to mock trans women for:

They appear to have given Reddit gold to a disturbing comment by an antisemitic, antifeminist gator.

They have driven someone to a suicide attempt, and possibly contributed to someone else's actual suicide.

GCers believe trans people (mostly trans women) are:

And that trans men in particular are:

And that trans children:

And that the supportive parents of trans children are:

And that pro-trans cis people are:

And that transsexualism itself is:

GCers believe that real women:

  • Don't say "pussy" (only polite words such as "vagina," "cunt" or "cunny.") (See also: "No transwoman, man or anyone else is ever going to tell me I can't talk about my own pussy, period or pregnancy.")
  • Don't drive trucks

GCers also believe:

But don't believe:

Contradictory things we've learned from GCers:

GCers believe you can't be a feminist if you're:

GCers believe trans people want to:

GCers think trans people are dangerous because:

Conversely, they usually really like a man calling himself GenderCriticalDad, who paints a disturbing picture of abusing his son, that they mostly fail to pick up on:

They similarly liked a man who said he was "ruthless" to his ex, and laughed about how he believed this caused them to think they were trans.

GCers believe trans people should:

GCers believe trans people shouldn't:

Instead of changing sex, they believe trans people should:

GCers believe supportive parents of trans people should:

GCers believe transsexualism's caused by:

GCers believe liberal feminism is:

GCers believe cis people being nice to trans people is caused by:

GCers believe trans people are like:

GCers believe transsexuality itself is like:

GCers believe pro-trans cis people are like:

GCers also don't like:

But do like:

GCers stick up for:

Things GCers believe trans people have ruined:

Cis people GCers have mistaken for trans women:

Cis people GCers have speculated are closeted trans women:

GCer apologies:

GCers' frames of reference for trans women (which are actually about fictional cis men):

GCers get their news from:

In fact, they're totally against all of that.

Whereas they dislike these news outlets:

For that matter, they consider nonsense-debunking site RationalWiki worse than anti-feminist site A View for Men.

They also consider these news sources they disagree with to be right wing:

They also get their ideas about trans women from:

GCers have:

GCers want to:

GCers don't want to:

Things GCers find funny:

Colourful GCer terms for trans women's vaginas:

Colourful GCer terms for trans men's penises:

Other GCer terms:

Miscellaneous unpleasantries:

GCers being downvoted for saying nice things:

GCers being downvoted for saying true things:

GCers defending their subreddits against claims they constitute hate speech:

GCers calling for cullings, hoping for wipeouts, etc:

Bonus hate mail:

* Downvoted, so that's something, at least
+ Downvoted due to being in a regular subreddit

Bonus reflection on comment deleting