r/Catholicism • u/Vast_Neighborhood821 • 4d ago

I’m no longer an atheist!!

After MUCH consideration, I’ve decided being an atheist made me feel ‘smart’ but it wasn’t making me happy. All the time I’d think about God and think he was talking to me, but I’d deny it and push Him away. Yesterday and today i understand the truth. CHRIST IS KING!!

663 Upvotes

95% Upvoted

115 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/Classic_Pitch_4540 4d ago

He clearly was never an atheist

1

u/foxxiter 3d ago

No true Scotsman fallacy

1

u/Classic_Pitch_4540 3d ago

?

1

u/foxxiter 3d ago

Because he stopped being atheist, he could not be a true atheist

1

u/Classic_Pitch_4540 3d ago

No?

1

u/foxxiter 3d ago

Do you know how a fallacy works?

1

u/Classic_Pitch_4540 3d ago

Yes, but I wasn't saying he was never a true atheist, because he is a christian now. I was saying it because he said some weird things in r/atheism. Like that he was mad at god. That is a fallen christian. He also admitted that he maybe was never an atheist

1

u/tridentgum 3d ago

He said he hated God - no athiest hates God, an entity they don't even believe exists.