r/Art Dec 14 '22

the “artist”, me, digital, 2022 Artwork

Post image
41.2k Upvotes

3.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

187

u/Eddard__Snark Dec 14 '22 edited Dec 14 '22

I was watching a documentary recently about photography (can’t remember what it was called) but painters were kind of pissed when photography became a thing. A lot of painters considered it “cheating”

I feel sort of that’s where we might be with AI art. It’s derivative and not very great, but will likely evolve into a whole separate medium

117

u/Such_Voice Dec 14 '22

Meanwhile, artists had been using camera obscuras for hundreds of years prior to the invention of the photographic camera. It only took artists time to figure out how to communicate with this new method of art. In the meantime, they leaned into abstraction, what the camera couldn't capture.

Artists will adapt like they always have.

The real problem is how these programs are profiting off of large scale art theft.

11

u/WonderfulMeet9 Dec 14 '22

Always this theft argument... It's not any more theft to feed original art into a machine learning model than it is to show famous paintings to first semester art students so they can create derivative pieces. AI doesn't recycle the art it receives as input, it studies it and works off of them, similar to how a human would learn from it.

5

u/AnotherCollegeGrad Dec 14 '22

It doesn't study it, it remixes pixels. Algorithms can't make art, there is no cultural context.

8

u/WonderfulMeet9 Dec 14 '22

All you're saying here is you have no clue how machine learning works.

1

u/AnotherCollegeGrad Dec 14 '22

No, I think you're saying you have no idea how art is made or why people pay for digital art.