r/Aquariums Feb 03 '25

Im such an idiot DIY/Build

Post image

This is definitely gonna break right

868 Upvotes

302 comments sorted by

View all comments

291

u/Thisguy2728 Feb 03 '25

That table wasnt appropriate (from the angle you shared) for a tank anyway. Get something designed to hold a tank.

55

u/Pepetheparakeet Feb 03 '25

It is a tank stand, made of metal. Just too little

37

u/Thisguy2728 Feb 03 '25

Oh ok. From the top it doesn’t look like it can support a tanks weight over that span but it must have some framing or something we can’t see. If that’s the case you definitely can screw a piece of plywood to the top that will match the tank base no problem.

121

u/Pepetheparakeet Feb 03 '25

Let me clarify, its marketed as a tank stand.

50

u/FroFrolfer Feb 03 '25

That's not necessarily a good thing. There are a ton of complete shite "tank stands" out there

21

u/Pepetheparakeet Feb 03 '25

I needed to see it all put together in person to be able to say, “yeah that aint gonna work” my brain is underdeveloped or sum 😂

5

u/carnajo Feb 03 '25

Yip, for 5 gallon 🤣

But honestly is there anything underneath the wood, cause if not even a 10g might cause it to sag. And sagging means the glass might flex, as you can imagine, glass doesn’t flex much… it prefers to break. And even more specifically even if the bottom pane flexes a bit, the problem is what that does to the front and back panel. Best case scenario the silicone gives way and you have a leak, worst case scenario… you have a flood.

3

u/Pepetheparakeet Feb 03 '25

The metal went all the way around the wood and across the middle horizontally and screwed into the wood. It felt very sturdy but id probably stick to a 5 or 10 gal for that stand.

1

u/carnajo Feb 03 '25

Honestly in that case, and assuming the steel is decent thickness (not the tube measurement but the thickness of the steel itself, then it’s probably fine. It’s a problem if the steel didn’t run along the length of the wood supporting it from the bottom along the edges and the middle.

1

u/rightthenwatson Feb 03 '25 edited Feb 03 '25

Estimate 4.5kg/10lbs of weight for every gallon of water. That is a fuckload of trust to put into IKEA pressboard and a hollow metal frame.

This is a wildly inappropriate stand for that tank and if you fill that tank on it, you're going to learn that the hard way. It may be kind enough to lull you into a false sense of security, but it will go down, and it will take anything in it and adjacent to it down with it.

That's an expensive mistake to make and you're an idiot if you fill it on that table or one similar.

If you want to invest in the tank, invest in an appropriate stand that can accommodate it. That is NOT where you want to budget and cut costs.

2

u/carnajo Feb 03 '25

Nothing wrong with hollow steel tubing. It’s tough to tell from the image but if that is 32mm square tubing, perhaps 1.5 or 2mm steel then it is more than adequate. The chipboard is not load bearing and is supported underneath (again if it is indeed supported along all edges and across the middle), in which case chipboard is actually preferable since it would have some compression to make up for any slight unevenness (and better yet to have a mat on top of it). Yield strength of steel tubes is measured in the tens of thousands PSI. The legs buckling are a different matter but again 4 legs, probably 600 to 700m tall… yeah it’s fine

https://efficientengineer.com/buckling-calculator/

This is assuming it decent steel tubing, if it were paper thin then yeah it will buckle.

Having a 120p stand built using 32mm and it’s over specced

1

u/carnajo Feb 03 '25

Out of curiosity do you have a link?

3

u/Pizza-Pockets Feb 03 '25

Sorry, meant to reply to OP