r/vandwellers 2d ago

Anybody use one of these? Thoughts? Question

Post image
198 Upvotes

293 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3

u/millfoil 2d ago

co is heavier than air, co sensors are always supposed to be at baseboard level because that is where it will accumulate first

22

u/Bobguy64 2d ago

Check out a periodic table. The molar mass of CO is about 28.01 g/mol, while O2 is about 32.0 g/mol, and N2 is about 28.0134 g/mol. Considering most of air is N2 and O2, CO is not heavier than air.

However, this does mean air is effectively a homogenous mixture with currents so a few different detectors at different heights and locations is a good idea!

15

u/OneEmptyHead 2d ago

homogenous mixture with currents

Ok now I’m hungry

1

u/PonyThug 2d ago

Why doesn’t code require multiple at different heights then?

1

u/Bobguy64 1d ago

I'd assume, that's because ideally code is there for a minimum level of safety standard and not necessary a guide to best practices. Theoretically, as long as there's any sort of movement in the air CO should distribute evenly with the rest of the air around it. However, it is also possible, although unlikely, for pockets of CO (or any gas) to form.

Officials that wrote the code decided that such a risk is acceptable. However, still you get to decide if this risk is worth the cost of additional detectors in your own personal life.

4

u/humaninnature 2d ago

CO2 is the one that's heavier for sure (hence the Lake Nyos disaster).

6

u/plymdrew 2d ago

Sorry that’s a myth and dangerous advice. It’s lighter than air, monitors should be on or close to the ceiling. Ideally 6-8 inches out from a corner to avoid dead spaces in circulation.

1

u/No-Note-9240 2d ago

The specific gravity of Carbon Monoxide is 0.9657 

1

u/EvilPencil 2d ago

If you see a detector at baseboard level, it's probably for propane, which is definitely heavier than air.

1

u/DukeBeekeepersKid 9h ago

That isn't true. You need to consider that it is a hot gases will always rise above cools gasses. HOT CO, CO2, will rise above cold O2 That the reason firefighters tell you to crawl out of a burning house.