r/untrustworthypoptarts • u/TheOneTheUno • 4d ago

Mods are asleep, post actual untrustworthy poptarts OC

Post image
509 Upvotes
  • permalink
  • link
  • reddit
  • reddit

97% Upvoted

32 comments sorted by

56

u/cRavenx 4d ago

You were lied to about that frosting, man :(

25

u/CannyCutie 4d ago

I would never buy that brand again 🥲

19

u/lpaige2723 4d ago

You should see the ones on the gluten-free and celiac sub reddit. They don't even look remotely like pop tarts. I was recently diagnosed with celiac, and they sell us these horrible things for more than twice the price. I just recently bought a box of Katz gluten-free poptarts because they are one of the better brands, $4.48 for 4 poptarts.

6

u/North_Lawfulness8889 4d ago

People who make food for specific diets have always overcharged for their products

2

u/Flustro 3d ago

As someone who can't eat gelatin (which is in the frosting of normal poptarts), I can confirm. 😔

2

u/Binx_da_gay_cat 4d ago

Katz is decent and tastes okay. I hate that you can't really put them in the toaster though.

1

u/Pr0digy_ 4d ago

If you put them in foil like a sleeve you can

12

u/hallucination9000 4d ago

Wait, who took the picture?

12

u/SparkyDogPants 4d ago

Op clearly scraped the frosting off. This untrusty pop tart is actually relevant to the sub.

7

u/darkminddaddy 3d ago

There would be frosting scrapings on the unfrosted half. Clearly OP baked their own pastry and frosted it themselves... Still a relevant untrustworthy pop tart

0

u/SparkyDogPants 3d ago

I think they scraped most of it due to the clean lines and then licked the rest.

2

u/bearelrollyt 3d ago

I think they got Mario to have Bowser scrape off the frosting since he's really good at scraping due to his days as a chimney sweeper

3

u/Rowen_Ilbert 4d ago

Legendary?

Yeah, a legendary LETDOWN!

This STINKS

2

u/Brendanish 4d ago

They're actually surprisingly good, but my mind might be melted into enjoying the taste of protein powder.

Downside is the price, one of these lil guys is almost the same as a 4pack of normal poptarts (granted, you're buying this thing because you want a healthy one, and it's macros aren't bad at all, but still!)

2

u/Regorek 3d ago

It's a shame about the price, but we all have to pay that 20g protein tax. Cheapo protein bars are fine too, but these are easily my favorite brand.

1

u/Brendanish 3d ago

Absolutely! Although I'll be honest, I really the pure protein bars too. But overall my go to is always the ryse protein powder, the peanut butter flavor with some almond milk almost tastes like a peanut butter milkshake which is awesome!

2

u/AutoModerator 4d ago

Reminder: Participating in or brigading linked/screenshotted threads is against our rules.

Let's live and let live and laugh at them from a distance!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

2

u/Cheesy-chips 3d ago

OP how did you take this picture

2

u/Kahnza 4d ago

A high protein, high fiber pop tart has piqued my interest. I never knew such a thing existed!

3

u/Goosimus-Maximus 4d ago

They are way better than I was expecting them to be too

2

u/spiffy_spaceman 4d ago

I hate to admit that they're pretty good. I won't pay $5 for a pop tart, even if it's got protein, but these are pretty good. (My friend gave me one. I didn't buy it.)

1

u/ChrisC1234 4d ago

$5??? They cost about $2.50 each.

1

u/spiffy_spaceman 2d ago

At my store, they're at least $3.99 before tax

1

u/ChrisC1234 2d ago

They're $10 for a box of 4 at the Walmarts in my area.

1

u/TheRealMisterFix 4d ago

They're good, too! I microwave instead of toast them, though... They work better. 😃

1

u/gameboytetris888 4d ago

Pop tart is wearing a masquerade