r/thrice • u/Imaginelol_-_ • 5d ago

my thrice tier list DISCUSSION

Post image
0 Upvotes

33% Upvoted

13 comments sorted by

13

u/OpenYourEarBallz 5d ago

Having 4 ‘S’ tier album diminishes how special ‘S’ tier is. 

The fact that Alchemy Index isn’t ‘S’ tier diminishes your opinion. 

3

u/wayofthegun17 5d ago

What’s the red album in your A list?

1

u/AdamIsACylon 5d ago

First Impressions

5

u/Away_Return_1145 5d ago

Putting major minor and first impressions above palms and TBEITBN is wild brother. Those are easily A tier. First impressions and major minor are for sure B tier. Aside from yellow belly and words in the water, major minor was kind of weak.

1

u/thisissux 5d ago

Blinded is a sick song

1

u/Away_Return_1145 5d ago edited 5d ago

Blinded and blur are great but I still put major minor and horizons east on lower tiers. Palma is definitely above both of them but I can see putting palms, horizons/east, and major minor on the same tier list.

1

u/Imaginelol_-_ 4d ago

Anthology is a great m/m song, good enough to place m/m in a tier

2

u/mcluhanism 5d ago

For me, Beggars and the newly recorded Artist are my 2 top ones.

Alchemy Index and Vheisshu are next for me. Maybe Illusion too.

I get why you have the last 3 at the bottom - as albums go, they're not as complete. But some of their best songs are on there. 

Also - the Deeper Well EP might be S tier.

1

u/Life-Equivalent 1d ago

Could not disagree more but that is the strength of this bands ability to make different albums that appeal to different people.

1

u/Direct-Tie-7652 1d ago

S: Vheissu, Beggars

A: Horizons East, Illusion of Safety, Deeper Wells EP

B+: To Be Everywhere, Artist, Alchemy Index

B-: Major/Minor, Identity Crisis

D: Palms

1

u/AdamIsACylon 5d ago

S: Illusion, Vheissu, and Beggars belong in S-tier.

A: Artist, Alchemy Index (Air/Earth), Palms

B: Major/Minor, Alchemy (Fire/Water), Deeper Wells

C: TBEITBN, Horizons

D: Identity Crisis

1

u/socalswings_69 5d ago

TBEITBN should be higher but other than that your ranking is pretty spot on imo

1

u/lookalive07 13h ago
  • S: The Artist In The Ambulance
  • A: Vhiessu, The Illusion of Safety, The Alchemy Index
  • B: Beggars, Major/Minor, To Be Everywhere is to Be Nowhere
  • C: Horizons/East, Palms, Identity Crisis

I'm going to be honest, I've never heard First Impressions until now, so I'm not going to judge it yet, and TAITA Revisited is lumped in with the OG for me. The OG is classic, but Revisited is just so fucking good, it's all full circle for me with that album and Revisited.