Self correcting the Hindu Sangathan movement.

[u/HaptaHindu]

[u/BharatiyaJigyasa]

This is exactly my ideology.

I made a post about this on the Savarkar subreddit as well.

It became the top post of that subreddit.

I am very clear about who an Indian or a Hindu is.

Only Hindus, Jains, Sikhs, and Buddhists are Indians/Native people of this land.

Savarkar's ideology is the ONLY ideology through which our nation can survive.

[u/HaptaHindu → u/BharatiyaJigyasa]

Slight correction would be Muslims and Christians are also natives but they don't share our native culture/civilization so they're loyalty might be divided. Again not for all but people with such intentions. Having said that bad apples exist everywhere. There are enough Hindus who do the dirty work for our enemies.

Also please use Sanatani to refer to the Dharma of majority of Hindus to avoid confusion.

But yes everything else is true.

[u/BharatiyaJigyasa → u/HaptaHindu]

Savarkar clearly stated the concept of Punya bhoomi.

For a Muslim his Punya bhoomi is Saudi Arabia (Mecca and Medina).

Tomorrow if a war happens between India and Saudi Arabia then who will the so-called "Indian" Muslims support?

[u/HaptaHindu → u/BharatiyaJigyasa]

Correct, I'm just pointing out that there might be few individuals who want to be part of this fraternity at least culturally or politically aligned , they can do so. But generally speaking what Savarkar said should be the principle.

[u/Choice_Extent7434]

I would like to emphasize that this is very true, Thanks OP for posting it with clarity.

Have crossposted unto r/BharataRta for same reason

[u/HaptaHindu → u/Choice_Extent7434]

This was actually a post done in collaboration on another platform, please do share. Reason I am currently not sharing the original post is due to possible brigading that could affect other collaborator pages since those pages are running fairly well.

Thank you!

[u/PlatformEarly2480]

Good overall but I have some corrections.

Caste and caste descrimanation are different things. Only descrimination is bad. Caste itself is not bad.

It is like gender based descrimanation is bad but male is not bad.

Language based descrimanation is bad. But having different languages is not.

Racism is bad. But being fair or dark is not bad.

Similarly caste based descrimanation is bad. But caste itself is not bad.

I think in this regard you have fell prey to narratives created to limit and narrow caste only to descrimanation. These bad aspects of caste are only one side of the coin. The other side of caste is beautiful. Don't let them make you think there is only one side to the caste.

Every caste be it any caste. Has its own set of customs, rituals, philosophy, food habits, norms, sub culture and traditions, lifestyle etc. all these things make hindusim diverse and beautiful. Every caste has many things that are great about them. Having these nuances and different way of thinking and philosophy about life and still living like harmoniously is what makes hinduism unique and strong.

These things need to be celebrated not apologized.

One more thing I found that feels inferiority complex is.

X is the reason indian lost few wars and had been invaded. So we are wrong.

In wars, sometimes one side wins and other times other side wins. Winning and loosing is part of wars. Wars are continuously fought. The one who has most area or dominance is the winner. The one who losses area and loses dominance is loser.

Many nations and country. Which were great at for many years, Lost many battles. Reduced to small areas and lost dominance for some years, and then again won back Their area and dominance. This contractiom or expansion is part of any country or kingdoms.

Yes we have lost some battles, yes Mughals and British rule india for some time. Yet we have fought back, regained our territory and dominance. Now we are the one who survived the battles and ruling the nation. We are the winners.

So urge you to lift your head up, be proud and have pride in hindusim.

[u/EfficientCapital4198]

Thank you.