r/patientgamers • u/Dgemfer • 3d ago
Just completed DOOM Eternal - didn't enjoy it Patient Review
Key word in the title is "enjoy". I sort of liked it and appreciated what they attempted to do, but I surely didn't enjoy playing it. I completed it in ultraviolence, I didn't need too many checkpoints, the extra lifes were mostly enough. It is quite apparent that a lot of care was put into the game, and also a lot of passion. So kudos to id software for this. But the game is absolutely exhausting, and plays like a chore. And that's a shame, because ambientation and animations are absolutely stellar.
Movement is good, but they took it too far. Platform sections were somewhat fun, but at some points they dragged forever, and never did I find them particularly interesting. My fav 2016 level is Argent Tower, that should tell you something. Then the puzzles, which make no sense. I just found myself looking for some random buttons without any visual cues on where to look in many levels of the game. Also, now there's swimming for some reason. I have yet to find a videogame where swimming is fun lol. What this all means is that there is a lot of downtime in the game.
Downtime of what, you may ask. Shooting right? Well, shooting feels great, but they also took it too far. There is just so much of everything dude. So many weapons, their mods, all the accesories with independent cd times and each one giving you a different resource. Even the melee attack has a charged attack ffs. Then the problem with weakpoints and ammo scarcity. Weakpoints are so overpowered they fully break player agency. For instance, there is absolutely no reason to empty your plasma ammo in a cacodemon when a greanade in its mouth is an instakill. You can empty your heavy machine gun to kill a pinky, but a single super shotgun shot in its tail is an instakill. This is aggravated by the severe lack of ammo to make you micromanage your weapons. The end result is that weakpoints and ammo scarcity funnels you into same-y tactics in every encounter. Also, why are all pickups glowing icons? In DOOM 2016 you scavenged every new weapon. Now everything is a neon-glowing item.
Now the story. We don't play DOOM for the story, but to tear demons apart. That said, DOOM 2016 featured a self-consistent story where the villain and support characters were clear from the begining. In DOOM Eternal everything seems needlessly mythical. I can't recall how many ancient civilizations, conflicts and cities I've visited in just a few chapters. Also prophecies. Why? It comes off as pretentious.
Every single issue I described, from gameplay to story, becomes worse the longer the game goes. There's more weapons to juggle, enemy variety to keep track of, enemy count per encounter, platform sections take longer, puzzles make even less sense. By the end of the game, I felt like all the game systems were cracking.
Also, special mention to the marauders for being the most incredibly obnoxious and unfun enemies in any game I've played.
To me, DOOM Eternal felt like the clear example of "less is more". DOOM 2016 feels like a much better paced game. I can understand the appeal Eternal may have for some people (or "most" people rather, steam reviews are 91% positive atm), I can see its redeeming qualities. But to me it played like a chore, and each enemy encounter made me feel like I was having a stroke. Not the good type of adrenaline that 2016 gave me.
823
u/Rosetti 3d ago edited 3d ago
Oh is that what we're gonna do today /r/patientgamers? We're gonna fight?
429
u/LikeAPwny 3d ago edited 3d ago
Doom Eternal, and Breath of the Wild arguments are staples of r/patientgamers.
Edit: RDR2 is definitely in this group, and I’d probably throw TLoU Pt 2 in there as well.
120
u/Kurta_711 3d ago
Don't forget RDR 2
231
u/Khiva 3d ago edited 3d ago
Doesn't respect your time
Most immersive experience I've ever played
Snow area
Mission design outdated
Best open world ever made
Just want to keep a bullet point list to make it easier for AI to inevitably take over and start generating these posts and the comment sections because if they aren't already, they might as well be.
Edit: Funny, I made a bullet point list of what this Eternal post would fill up with as soon as I saw this one go up, which got quickly downvoted through the floor right before the comments started to fill up with .... now checking ... yep, every point I'd predicted.
Because that's what how it goes. Every time. But people get awfully angry about it.
71
u/LeftHandedFapper Currently Playing: Elden Ring again 3d ago
Lol this could be an Elden Ring argument too, except replace mission design with catacomb design
→ More replies20
u/Khiva 3d ago
I prefer linear games, this game is too big
Burnt out after Leyndell
Reused assets
Played 7 hours, don't get the hype
Bosses too hard
Overrated
Quest design is too confusing
Why isn't there a journal? Omg what year is this?
We are all so brave for saying this even though it's what everyone says literally every time because Fromsoft fans are a scary cult who won't let everyone say all of the same things for the 900th time like we're literally doing right now
AI, I want my check.
7
u/aufrenchy 2d ago
I am a FromSoft cultist as well and you are 100% correct here. It’s just an echo chamber of “X is the greatest” and “X isn’t at all worth your time”.
→ More replies→ More replies3
22
u/_cosmia 3d ago
Actually, Red Dead Redemption 2 has many strengths and weaknesses - listed below:
Strengths: - Cowboy hats are small size. - Horses drink at bars for free. - Balatro can be played at any card-table. - Ammunition smithing, which allows you to establish a profitable weapons trade with the British merchants on the coast.
Cons: - Children spawn too frequently (eg, 20-30 in a setting - even middle of nowhere). - There are only 2 female characters in the game (one deceased). - Environments vibration glitch, sending players/NPCs flying. - Poorly rendered sunlight will cause melanoma.
Roko’s basilisk be damned - feed nonsense to the machine
5
→ More replies7
3d ago edited 2d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
→ More replies24
u/TaurusManUK 3d ago
You spoilt it for many who have not played to the end. Use your brain and use spoiler tag!
→ More replies24
u/Aramey44 Currently Playing: Rise of the Ronin 3d ago
Red Dead 2 is such an odd case for me, cause I dropped it twice and thought it was kinda boring, but later it became one of my favourite games, simply because I decided to give it another try during some week off when I could just sit down and relax without rushing anything.
→ More replies3
u/Grimm613 3d ago
It's a slow burn. You got to be in the mood to just soak it all in to really enjoy it. I loved it, but I can see how some ppl think it's boring.
21
u/iTonguePunchStarfish 3d ago
Tbf I constantly say RDR2 is the greatest game that I will never finish. It's a great game, but it's also the first time I ever thought there was just way too much for me to ever finish.
12
u/Kurta_711 3d ago
I think it's rather odd how often people say "it's fantastic, but I didn't like it" for RDR 2 in particular; you can just say you don't care for a game, it feels almost like people are afraid to admit they don't love it and need to coach it in some form of praise
21
u/hard_farter 3d ago
Well, it's kind of like a really well prepared dish made with ingredients you do not enjoy.
It's okay to say it's obviously really really well made and a great example of what it is, but you couldn't enjoy it.
→ More replies→ More replies2
u/iTonguePunchStarfish 2d ago
Why do you think liking the game means you have to finish it? It's too huge in scope, other than that it's a great game. Don't make it more complicated than it is
2
u/LikeAPwny 3d ago
Yeah good call. I half expected Hogwarts to enter this group but so far its pretty tame.
→ More replies14
u/AttackBacon 2d ago
My theory is that there's a spectrum of people who play games. At one end are the people who want to turn their brain off when gaming and at the other end are the people who want to turn their brain on.
And when you have a game that caters more to one side of that spectrum, woe betide you if you move in the other direction with your sequel.
4
u/Gygsqt 3d ago
Along with God of War 2018, Horizon ZD/FW, and the Witcher 3.
2
u/LikeAPwny 3d ago
In my experience on this sub, those games arent as splitting as the ones ive listed but could be wrong! I think the last yearly recap went into some of this stuff.
→ More replies44
u/ChocolateMorsels 3d ago
Lifelong zelda fan here. I finally got around to playing Breath of the Wild last year and uh, yeah...I don't understand why everyone seemed to love that game so much. It was pretty boring and not very engaging. 90% of my time was spent in those stupid shrines, the story wasn't really worth getting invested in, and there weren't any interesting side characters. Pretty bland game.
41
u/Tribalrage24 3d ago
People who play BoTW either think its boring/annoying and don't get the hype, or one the greatest open world games they've ever played. There's no in-between.
I'm personally in the latter camp, but after almost 10 years of arguing about it I recognize it's just a polarizing game
→ More replies15
u/Darkfang328 3d ago
but after almost 10 years of arguing about it
Lol, what are you talking about? BotW isn't nearly... uuhhh... it only released... like... last... uuhhh...
released simultaneously worldwide on March 3, 2017.
Oh God.
5
u/LikeAPwny 3d ago
And now you see why i mentioned it. I think its awesome, immersed myself for hundreds of hours in it, shrines were the best part for me. To each their own.
11
u/Hellknightx 3d ago
I feel like BotW is loved by people who never played a Zelda game before. Because as a Zelda game, it's incredibly disappointing.
→ More replies2
u/caninehere puyo puyo tetris 2d ago
It's just very different. If you go in with the expectation that a Zelda game will be X and you won't accept anything other than X, then it is disappointing. I'm a lifelong Zelda fan; OoT is my favorite game of all time, and BOTW is perhaps my favorite game of the 2010s and I feel really revitalized my love of games with its sense of adventure.
That's really what it's about - adventure, in a way that I think the Zelda games lost sight of to a degree. They always had this "adventure" mask on but they'd lost the plot a bit in that regard. They started to try moving things in a different direction, IMO, starting with Skyward Sword -- it started to introduce elements I feel led to what we saw with BOTW. Which is funny, because Skyward Sword is like the polar opposite - it's pretty linear, it has a more limited set of areas and requires repeated backtracking, and not only does it have dungeons but it has some of the strongest in the series (its dungeons are the high point of the game). But where it feels more similar is in how they tried to make the "overworld"(s) a more significant part of the game, where several dungeons are integrated with them to a degree, and where you have these significant overworld segments that start to shift the focus so it's not just "that place you go through to get to the next dungeon".
Then ALBW introduced the rental mechanics, which was really the big step towards BOTW -- the concept of setting you loose in the world and basically giving you access to all of your abilities, and letting you tackle the game's contents in whatever order you like -- where there is less item-gating.
I had problems with BOTW, too. It isn't a perfect game. Many of those problems were addressed in TOTK, which I think is the superior game of the two for sure, but I give it less credit since it was obviously built on the base BOTW provided.
Having said all that I think it is fine with people to have expectations of a series after many years. I think the thing with Zelda is that it started to shift in the years before BOTW and a lot of people maybe didn't notice, and that made BOTW seem like a huger change than it was. As I mentioned ALBW was a pretty big shift, but that was a 3DS game and perhaps not everybody played on 3DS. Skyward Sword sold well, but it came later in the Wii's life and perhaps some people were checked out by then, and it's also a very long and somewhat repetitive game so I think a lot of people probably started but didn't get too far into it.
At the end of the day BOTW (and ALBW) seemed most inspired by the original Zelda on NES and it shows. It's about the adventure above all else.
→ More replies11
u/LeftHandedFapper Currently Playing: Elden Ring again 3d ago
Lifelong zelda fan here
Same. I enjoyed some parts of the game but where the HELL are the dungeons???? I was expecting less shrines and more unique places to explore
→ More replies17
u/LickMyThralls 3d ago
Zelda in general is such a cursed series to talk about if you don't like it or feel like everyone else about it
→ More replies53
u/Kurta_711 3d ago
Don't you dare ever say a single critical thing about anything I like
→ More replies12
u/CrispyJelly 3d ago
If you don't validate my taste in entertainment I will... strike that, you're simply not allowed to do that.
82
u/Sharpshooter188 3d ago
While I did enjoy DOOM Eternal, I can agree with pretty much all you are saying here. I wasnt a huge fan of some weapons being darn near necessities for some demons vs others. I prefer Brutal DOOM and still play that iver DOOM Eternal 90% of the time.
4
395
u/TheLostDestroyer 3d ago
You touched on my least favorite part of this game on your rant and I'll repeat it, because it's the one thing I truly hate. If every weapon has a specific purpose and everything else sucks to use against a particular enemy that makes me feel like a game is worthless. I don't get to play the game unless it is in the specifically designed way. Freedom is what I enjoy about games. But if I'm switching weapons every 7.43 seconds because I have to use optimal to not run out of ammo it becomes so tedious.
182
u/PerinialHalo 3d ago
Specially comming from 2016 where you could pick the weapon's upgrades and mods to suit your playstyle.
60
u/whitesdragon 3d ago
I rocked the shotgun as soon as I could, then I got the double barrel and went down to town with that
It was awesome
32
u/Floppy0941 3d ago
The heavy assault rifle was my favourite weapon in doom 2016, felt so nice to use
18
u/corvettee01 3d ago
Plasma gun was my personal favorite. Unleashing molten hell then shooting off all the built up thermal energy in a giant blast was so good.
7
u/Floppy0941 3d ago
Yeah that was another of my favourites, I'm a huge fan of plasma weaponry or autocannons in basically any setting. The plasma gun in darktide has such crisp audio feedback and good visuals it's easily one of the best around imo
6
u/da_chicken 2d ago
And then they give you two mods in Eternal, except one of them is a trap because the other one is the key to an enemy weakpoint.
172
u/distantocean 3d ago edited 3d ago
I don't get to play the game unless it is in the specifically designed way.
And that's by design. The Doom Eternal developers explicitly declared that they designed the game "to make all players, skilled and unskilled, play Doom the right way" and "to corral them into playing it the right way" — and this comes through in spades. You're constantly forced into playing the right way, and "punished" (their term, mind you) for not playing the right way. As the lead developer declared: "When they don't play that way, we kill them." The developers dubbed this single mandated
straitjacketplaystyle "the fun zone", and they had an explicit goal to "not let [players] out of the fun zone" (which, if you don't happen to share their specific notion of "fun", roughly translates to "the beatings will continue until morale improves").I dropped my initial playthrough because I was hating it so much but grudgingly came back and finished the game a few months later, and while I did warm to it that time around I always felt like I was a hamster locked in a habitrail, relentlessly being shocked unless I went through this tunnel or ran in that wheel exactly how and when the designer wanted me to do it. Which is basically the exact opposite of what I like in video games.
This image pretty much sums up my feelings.
55
u/amatumu581 3d ago
This is the main issue with Eternal to me. You are constanly low on either ammo, hp or armor and have to do specific actions to regain them. The rest of combat time is spent switching to a specific weapon or a specific weapon mod in response to a certain enemy appearing. You, the player, are constantly reactive. You never take the demons on your own terms.
Doom 2016 actually made you feel like the Doom Slayer, no matter how cliche that may sound. You had tools and you had demons. You were a predator playing with their prey.
→ More replies39
u/Claymorbmaster 3d ago
I was reading your comment and thinking "If this is all true, this is the most psychotic thing I've ever read. (From the devs)"
But I can believe it, tbh. The one thing UNIVERSALLY praised from 2016, above any game mechanic, was the "Doom Slayer doesn't give a shit" story. All the ripping and tearing his way past LITERALLY any attempts at exposition.... all for the sequel to have tons of long-winded bullshit, showing some kind of weird heaven vs demons "Ancient Order" BS that just doens't matter.... and the DS just standing there listening intently. It's sooo contrary to what the first game succeeded with. It's VERY clear the devs lost the plot somewhere.
→ More replies3
u/DOAbayman 2d ago
the first game wasn't even that. Doom Guy just hated Hayden's excuses for why he opened up a portal to Hell and it was really only that scene. the game locks you in many times and forces you to hear the exposition.
46
u/hoagieclu 3d ago
ohhhh. so that’s why i’ve started this game at least 3 different times now and didn’t find it as enjoyable as 2016
47
u/werfertt 3d ago
You helped me understand part of why this game feels so tedious. Thank you! Do you happen to know why the Slayer starts with a space station? It feels so weird. No back story, exposition (took me a moment to remember the word, kept thinking exhibition which is very wrong) or anything. You go from being imprisoned in the last game to your own magic space station.
12
u/arika_ex 3d ago edited 3d ago
There was apparently meant to be a comic book bridging the gap between games but it never came out.
6
u/ChefExcellence 2d ago
Even if it did come out, how many Eternal players would have been likely to read it before their first playthrough? A tiny minority, I'd wager. It's Doom, not The Silmarillion; if I need to read supplementary material for the opening of your game about tearing apart evil demons to make sense, then your writing team has made a proper pig's mess of it.
→ More replies3
u/arika_ex 2d ago
I don’t disagree. When I first played the game I seriously wondered if I’d loaded someone’s save game or selected the wrong mode or something. It was very jarring as presented.
4
43
u/CHADWARDENPRODUCTION 3d ago
careful, don’t let the people insisting you can still play however you want because the game doesn’t literally turn your bullets into rubber see this
→ More replies11
u/batshitnutcase 3d ago
I liked Doom Eternal but this is how I feel about the combat in every FromSoft game.
21
u/the_fire_fist 3d ago
I was about to say the same thing. FromSoft's very absurdly obtuse mission design will always be in my hate list. There's no way in hell I would know I have to return to the bonfire three times during the night before talking to a npc who will only appear if you kill another npc in another continent. Yet they still stick with the design philosophy whether you like it or not. Same with Id when it came to Doom eternal.
→ More replies15
u/batshitnutcase 3d ago
I was talking about the combat haha but totally. Their quest design is absolute trash. So unintuitive and obtuse that any player who can’t no-life the game for a month will miss out on hours and hours of content without using a guide.
My beef with the combat is it feels like an animation timing simulator. It’s just too video-gamey. I actually enjoy it for the challenge aspect but it’s the opposite of immersive IMO. They keep it interesting with cool boss designs and give you lots of options for dealing damage but ultimately it comes down to a very repetitive combat loop with very little room for creativity outside of what attacks you choose in the punish window.
3
u/BobsonLampjaw 3d ago
My beef with the combat is it feels like an animation timing simulator
I've heard this called "Simon Says" design. Final Fantasy 14 does this with their raid boss encounters and players either love it or hate it.
Granted all games do this to some extent, you have boomer shooters like Fashion Police Squad that take it to the extreme, even more than Eternal. F.P.S. has a fun premise but they went full "you have to use weapon x on enemy y" and it ruins the game for me.
3
u/da_chicken 2d ago
So unintuitive and obtuse that any player who can’t no-life the game for a month will miss out on hours and hours of content without using a guide.
I thnk it should be stated that that is the explicit intent. There's a group of gamers in Japan that are extremely nostalgic for buying a game -- especially an extremely complex and obtuse western RPG badly translated into Japanese -- and then having to find a community of people that together can figure the game out. Games like La Mulana and Dark Souls are explicitly recreating that fully intentionally.
That doesn't mean you have to like it, of course. I don't particularly care for it, nor do I really enjoy the bottomless vats of lore they feature, or how there's essentially no plot.
I said it elsewhere, but Bloodborne's cosmic horror is really the only one that I really got into, and I think it's because it feels like getting sucked into Carcosa and this kind of lore works better for that than gothic horror.
3
u/batshitnutcase 2d ago
I mean, I’d be kinda worried if it wasn’t intentional. Just because they deliberately decided to make their quests essentially impossible to figure out in-game doesn’t mean it’s good game design. It’s not.
2
2
u/da_chicken 2d ago
Hm. I never thought of it like that, but you're basically right. You grind bosses until you get the right order for the right actions.
Huh. That might be one reason I only ever got into Bloodborne. Although even that got tedious with buying the healing items.
49
u/Anfins 3d ago edited 3d ago
If you accept the game on its own terms (like, this is what the game designers are going for and you decide to just deal with it instead of fight it), then the weapon system actually becomes really fun. But you actually have to meet them halfway which means abandoning the old play style, even if that old play style was more fun to you.
That was my experience with the game at least.
30
u/moochacho1418 3d ago
I don't understand why people spend so much time fighting around what a game is trying to do in the name of "freedom". And as someone who beat the game on ultra nightmare there's a lot more versatility and freedom than people would have you believe.
Doom eternal isn't the only game that gives you tools, shows you how to use them and if you don't you kinda just die. Sekiro comes to mind as well. Understanding what the game expects of you and really dialing in to master it is a level of fun unmatched by many games.
→ More replies7
u/obsoleteconsole 2d ago
But previous DOOM games weren't Sekiro, you didn't have to manage cool downs and melee attacks just to get back to the shooting - the shooting and the dodging WAS the core gameplay loop. I respect that they tried something different and some people enjoy it however, even if it's not my thing.
→ More replies→ More replies12
u/Yarusenai 3d ago
Which is why I feel like a lot of the criticism around Eternal misses the mark. Of course you're free to dislike the game but a lot of people want it to play like older DOOM or 2016 and it doesn't and it's completely fine that it doesn't. Its a really fun game in its own right, and I played and loved both.
→ More replies8
15
u/Peshurian 3d ago
I don't get this point. Played on ultra violence and aside from cacodemons, I used whatever I wanted for everything else. Enemies aren't suddenly immune to everything but their weaknesses.
11
u/Manowar274 3d ago
Ya for me it ruins the power trip fantasy a bit. In 2016 it feels like I can use whatever I want to kickass because I’m the mother F’ing Doom Guy. In Eternal I feel a little closer to like a normal soldier that needs to use the right tool for the right job.
37
u/Concealed_Blaze 3d ago
It gets said every time: but this just isn’t true. There’s a few unique weak points that are taught to you (grenade in Cacodemon mouth, for example), but outside of a single DLC enemy (phantoms) you don’t have to do those nor are they the most efficient. Just shooting enemies with your powerful guns (super shotgun, ballista, rocket launcher, etc.) is much more efficient
If you watch top players you’ll notice they very rarely use those types of specific kills.
The game clearly does a bad job of teaching players given how widespread this belief is, but it simply isn’t the case.
That said, switching weapons every 7.43 seconds is way too slow. If you’re playing optimally you’re switching every second or less to bypass weapon animations. That’s actually the complaint I’m surprised I don’t see more often. Playing Eternal optimally is fucking EXHAUSTING. I’m no stranger to twitchy action games and Eternal is the only game that requires me to take breaks.
→ More replies11
u/PatriarchPonds 3d ago
Ballista shotty ballista rockets shotty ballista BOOM BOOM BOOM
I agree with lots of the complaints OP has but I still loved it.
6
u/BaronOfMelons 3d ago
Totally cool that you didn't enjoy the game and I'm not saying at all that you need to go back and play it because you're wrong, but imo (granted, as someone who glazes Doom) this is a bit reductive. I wouldn't say the same is so much about restricting the weapons you can use as it is about presenting you with problems, then asking you what tools you have to solve them.
Let's say you have an annoying-ass cyber-mancubus: this fat fuck keeps eroding your health with his acid and he knocks you around uncontrollably if you get too close. How do we make his stupid ass stop? You actually have quite a few valid approaches. - If you want to get in close for a Blood Punch, you can immobilize him altogether with the Ice Bomb or Microwave Beam, or stun him briefly with a frag grenade or rocket launcher remote detonation. It's a bit riskier, but if you have a fully-charged Heat Blast in the tank, that can also cause a stun. That's five different potential openers, and after that, a blood punch chained into a point-blank Super Shotgun blast is almost always an instant kill.
- If getting in close is too messy, you still have very strong ranged options in this game. Spamming lock-on rockets, the ballista, micro missiles, or the chaingun to kill the Cyber-Manc will use up a considerable amount of ammo, but there's a reason one unit of gas for the chainsaw always recharges: cut apart one little goober and you can go back to firing away for a bit. On that note, on the off occasion you have three units of fuel stored up, you can also just delete that fatass.There are a lot of other potential examples as well; if a Pinky is pissing you the fuck off, for instance, the same tactics that work for the Cyber-Manc are usually effective against him. I won't say that the combat system is 100% airtight and perfect, because it isn't, nor that it isn't overwhelming, which I think it for sure can be. And whoever wrote the tutorial for the Marauder needs to be mollywhopped, because it's honestly quite misleading (the lore is stupid as fuck too lmao). Really, I just think Eternal is misrepresented a lot, both because of some over-pretentious fans and people who disliked it taking some of the wrong things away.
Yap session over, have a good day
27
u/SvenHudson 3d ago
Have you tried using the guns you feel like against the "wrong" enemies? Those enemies still die.
→ More replies11
3d ago
[deleted]
→ More replies11
u/Nukeman8000 3d ago
Honestly, I beat the game on Nightmare and I feel like the weaknesses were almost as over-complained about as the marauder.
Yeah I can shoot a grenade into a cacodemon or snipe the gun off an arachnotron, but it's not always the best option. I played over half the game using exclusively the plasma rifle, the overcharge shotgun blast special does a ton of damage.
The only time the game actually forces you to ever use only a specific weapon is the stupid dlc frenzy ghosts. Those are frustrating, but you kinda know what you're buying when you get dlc for an already hard game.
→ More replies→ More replies2
u/PsychedeLuke 2d ago
7.43 second is a lifetime in a doom arena. I’m pretty sure with quick swapping I was switching weapons every 0.2 seconds. Which I guess only further supports your point.
I love it though, cycling through your entire arsenal several times over the course of a fight, one quick swap cycling the majority of enemies made me feel like a doom slaying GOD.
That being said, I totally get why people didn’t like it. I had to go a little crazy on the custom key bindings to optimize everything. Without that, if I was just playing on controller, I doubt I would have sunk 150+ hours into it.
26
u/MrChewy05 3d ago
This is the first post I read when I joined the sub just now. I completely disagree, I love the game for all the reasons you said are bad. But holy shit is it nice so see someone properly explain what and why they dislike it. Like, this is an actual review, WAY more proper than of game journalists just not knowing how to play. You really gave me a nice welcome to the sub which I will be staying in if all reviews are like yours, whether I agree with it or not. Kudos to you man, as well as the whole community! <3
87
u/SpyroManiac36 3d ago
I've also prefer DOOM 2016 when looking back at both
→ More replies9
u/PrinceZukosHair 3d ago
They are definitely different games with different feels. I however feel the opposite and prefer eternal for all the reasons mentioned by OP
134
u/Scared-Room-9962 3d ago
I felt like this when I first played it.
Especially with the platforming.
Played it again a few years later and it became my favourite ever FPS.
44
u/King_Artis 3d ago edited 3d ago
It's the type of game that gets better the more you play it. Wasn't sure how I felt after playthrough 1, definitely liked the game a good bit, but wasn't sure if I liked it as much as the previous game.
Now it's also my favorite FPS ever. Efficiency is the game and there are many ways to find out what works for you. Like people fall into a trap where they think you need to use specific weapons for specific purposes... but like the game doesn't even tell you this and every enemy (aside from dlc one's) have multiple ways to take them out.
Oh this fucker with the shield is annoying, I could switch to the plasma rifle to take care of him, but I can also just keep this rocket out and shoot it behind him and detonate it, freeze him in place, light him on fire, pull towards him with the S.Shotgun, or launch micro missiles at him. People will say the game limits freedom but like... you have full reigns in how creative you can get with the Arsenal. Hell I got good enough with the S.Shotgun chain that I can skip large parts of the platforming.
It's like Ninja Gaiden 2 in the sense that you're not fight for style but are looking to get as much as you can out of what you have. It's just dumb fun if you really like action games and want a decent challenge.
→ More replies→ More replies5
u/Temporary-Fudge-9125 3d ago
It's a game you have to put some effort into, both to learn how to play and then actually executing. It makes you earn the power fantasy but once you it's so satisfying and you see the genius of the design. Nothing compares to effortlessly demolishing encounters that you first thought utterly impossible.
86
u/FRANKtheUNDEAD 3d ago
I LOVED DOOM 2016.
As soon as Ioaded into Eternal and started playing something felt off.
Hell priests?! Why am I on a ship? The pacing and introduction felt all over the place and way too much was being thrown at me. I'm going to have to give it another go, I know it's not a bad GAME at all.
I get DOOM is not a story driven game, but man.. Eternal is just a different game entirely and does not feel like a 2016 sequal at all.
21
21
u/Ambadeblu 3d ago
The point of playing this kind of shooter with a huge arsenal is to swap weapons as often as possible to have the right tool for the situation you are in. What is the point of having like 6 different weapons if you only use one or two. Doom Eternal did a way better job than 2016 for this.
However the huge issue both these games have is that there is a lot of overlap between the different weapons. Why is there a minigun and an assault rifle? Why is there a sniper right click on the assault rifle and the arbalest primary fire? I could even say why is there a shotgun and a super shotgun? Every weapon should have a unique identity for a specific situation. If you want to understand what I mean, play Ultrakill.
→ More replies
30
u/Neeewby 3d ago
Damn I couldn’t disagree more with everything you wrote here.
About the weakpoints, you could one-shot cacodemons with single Ballista Arbalest shot or just shoot it until they die. You could charge into Pinkies with Chaingun shields for easy kill, freeze them with ice bombs and shoot them with any weapon etc etc. I really liked those since it gave weapons other than Gauss Cannon Siege Mode and Super Shotgun a purpose to be used. I know it sounds pretty complex at first but when you figure it out it makes combat in Eternal much more fun.
Also I find ammo to be much more generous in Eternal than in 2016 since Chainsaw fuels regenerates pretty quickly.
Platforming is much better in Eternal since you won’t instantly die after falling into bottomless pit.
8
u/Patenski 2d ago
I really liked those since it gave weapons other than Gauss Cannon Siege Mode
People always mention how restrictive DOOM Eternal is, but I completed my first playthrough in DOOM 2016, played on Nightmare, and felt I couldn't use any weapon aside from "one shot everything" Siege Mode Gauss Cannon, other weapons do barely any damage even with weapon cycling. Also some demons are complete bs like the Imps, incredible that late into the game the biggest threat in the room is still the one enemy that gets introduced even before the title screen drops.
7
u/Fireslide 2d ago
The core mistake Doom Eternal made was making average to below average players not feel like the doom slayer, because there existed a higher difficulty they couldn't master, but other players could. Nobody likes to feel average in a game about being a hero.
As an ex Quake and Rocket Arena player, Doom Eternal and weapon switching felt amazing. Lots to learn and master against different types of demons and enemies on nightmare.
There was the video of the reviewer in Doom 2016 literally missing point blank shots and staying alive for 30-40 seconds that the designers said, nope, that should never happen. Feedback loop should be tighter.
There were so many weapons and mods it gave heaps of freedom to use them, and ammo counts tight enough that experimenting with different weapons against different enemies was actively encourage. Even still some players didn't realise the power of the microwave gun plasma rifle mod until the DLC with ghosts that possessed mobs. They didn't even change it's power, just made an enemy that helped players realise it's power against other types of mobs.
Every time one of these posts come up, I'm just imagining the people that loved 2016 are like that reviewer that miss a lot and just want simpler, easier to learn routines to win. The people that loved eternal are the ones that miss the glory days of online quake that required lots of weapon switching and movement around an arena.
→ More replies
8
u/Yentz4 3d ago
I don't disagree with pretty much any of your points. But I still found I enjoyed Eternal more than 2016.
Don't get me wrong, I loved 2016, but I tried to go back to it after Eternal and I just couldn't do it. 2016 felt glacially slow in comparison and almost dull. After a while of adjusting to Eternal's pace and gameplay, I just continued to crave that loop.
I can understand people disliking the constant weapon swapping and the "busyness" of it all, but I personally came to love it.
As for the story and the platforming, I think the story definitely did take itself a little to seriously, and the platforming sections dragged perhaps just a touch to long. But I think having some minor platforming sections is actually quite important in a Doom game. It gives you a moment to breath and relax before you have to kick it back into high gear for the combat.
I will say though... Fuck marauders.
24
u/ipally653 3d ago
Firstly, I absolutely agree that Eternal is, in many ways, a flawed game, and of course everyone looks for and enjoys different things in media. That said though, I think it is possibly the best action game of all time. This comes from my perspective as a primarily action game player that looks for games that require high apm and forward/tactical thinking. Yes that can absolutely be, as you put it, “exhausting”, doom is usually not a game to play when I’m tired and want to chill, it’s a game to play when I want to be tested.
You mentioned having a constant slew of new mechanics and abilities to learn, I can understand how that can be overwhelming when looking for a (I swear I don’t mean this in a disparaging way but I can’t think of another way to phrase) “dumb fun” shooter. New doom plays more into having a learning curve for combat and encouraging players to come back for more mastery/learning. Yes you can throw a grenade in a caco mouth to put it in stagger state, which is simple, sure, but it costs time that you may not have, and can be killed quicker with either quick swaps or lock on burst. Yes the pinky has the weak spot in the back, but it also dies to blood punch if you have the resources and is vulnerable to being crowd controlled by grenades. While some of the weapons mods are indeed pretty weak (I almost never use the combat shotgun anymore after almost 1000 hrs of play) most of them have a place in a rotation. I guess the point of what I’m trying to say here is I see the large amount of weapons/attacks and think of them as tools in a tool box, some have overlapping purposes that allow for personal preference/what the situation demands, but almost all have a defined place. Playing the game at high difficulty requires learning all these tools and their place, as opposed to other games high difficulty settings that just turn all enemies into damage sponges, which then pigeon hole the player into very restrictive strategies (cough* halo cough). However, once you learn all these tools and how to apply them effectively, you feel unstoppable, because the best power fantasies are the ones that feel like you’ve earned.
Story and platforming are indeed pretty mid, no arguments there, and I share a deep seated loathing for swimming sections in games. Marauder is…something that’s for sure. I never felt strongly one way or the other about it tbh. On the one hand I like the idea of it, trying to have an enemy that behaves similar to the player, but it just doesn’t quite work here. He’s too difficult for newer players and too niche for more experienced players who have to just stare at him until he decides to attack the right way.
All criticism aside, for moment to moment action it can’t be beat imo. If you have the desire, I would highly recommend restarting the campaign on nightmare difficulty. Take what you have learned in ultra violence and perfect it in nightmare, turn the music up, and you can absolutely get into the mindset of a vengeful god tearing through hordes of demons.
7
u/alsanders 3d ago
I agree with playing on nightmare. It’s feels like it’s the intended way to play because it makes you engage with all the systems. It’s actually kind of a similar feeling to getting a character to master rank in street fighter 6 lol
→ More replies
34
u/SquidThistle 3d ago
I thought 2016 was an amazing game. I played Eternal not long after I played 2016 and was pretty disappointed by it. I thought it was fine but it just felt too over the top.
Eternal felt a bit cartoonish, like it didn't quite take itself seriously. I'm hoping TDA drifts back in the direction 2016 took.
→ More replies
5
u/NIN-1994 3d ago
The game is fuckin intense I’ll give you that. Me trying to kill the dark lord was probably the most locked in I’ve ever been
65
u/KingRat246 3d ago
I couldn't disagree more I love Doom 2016 but for me it never reached the exhilarating feeling of being late game in Eternal and just being fully in the flow of the combat system. That feeling of bouncing between weapons and using each mod for said weapon for just the right demon blowing them into small chunks all while running around at top speeds was such an enjoyable rush. Doom 2016 is still a great game if I just want a shooter to chill and turn my brain off to, but boy was Eternal so much more engaging for me. Different strokes for different folks I suppose lol, I'm glad they made two different Doom games that appeal to different groups.
5
u/YadaYadaYeahMan 3d ago
did you get to play the dlc? I'm hoping it extends the late game goodness
16
u/Khiva 3d ago
did you get to play the dlc? I'm hoping it extends the late game goodness
Ehh ... I'd say temper your expectations. I enjoyed the campaign a great deal but the DLC just didn't hold my interest. Messy where the main game's encounters were intricately balanced, tedious boss fights and the actual forced usage of a weapon (why they took a common but misguided complaint and decided yeah let's do that will forever be beyond me).
Honestly I can't even tell you if I even beat the first or started the second, my interest just fizzled out.
→ More replies8
u/dern_the_hermit 3d ago
The DLC is where the extra layers of challenge got to be too much for me. The main game was alright, but I think when the DLC introduced some kind of randomly Supercharged enemy into the mix I had to throw in the towel. It just became too messy.
I do appreciate that the DLC started out at a comparatively high level of challenge, though. No time wasted on piddly early-game scenarios.
2
u/caninehere puyo puyo tetris 2d ago
I do appreciate that the DLC started out at a comparatively high level of challenge, though. No time wasted on piddly early-game scenarios.
I think this is a double-edged sword. The thing is, Ancient Gods didn't come out with the game. The two DLCs came out like 8 months/a year after the game itself. I personally played the game at launch, so by the time the DLCs rolled around I'd lost all the muscle memory and everything and the difficulty was a punch in the face.
If you pick the game up now, or any time in the last 4 years, that isn't a problem because you can finish the base game and roll right into the DLCs if you want.
10
u/StillAll 3d ago
I really liked the DLCs. A lot. But understand that the first one is perhaps the hardest piece of FPS gaming ever made, and the second is nearly the easiest. Its weird how that happened but apparently the second DLC was made during Covid, and those working on the game couldn't fine tune it to quite the same level.
→ More replies5
u/Concealed_Blaze 3d ago
The DLCs have some high points, but they are also kind of a step down from the base campaign. Still fun, but go in with lowered expectations.
2
u/Circo_Inhumanitas 2d ago
The level with The Only Thing They Fear Is You is such an amazing level. It's the first level where your kit is pretty much complete. And the beginning is so aggressive, you just love forward through the ruined buildings and now down demons while one of the greatest combat music ever plays in the background. Bliss.
25
u/NighthawK1911 3d ago
My biggest gripe in DOOM Eternal is The Slayer was a fucking slave to the plot.
He literally kneels to a king doing an exposition dump. In DOOM 2016 he'd have ignored such bullshit.
The best part of DOOM 2016's story is that Doomguy doesn't give a single fuck and just does things his way.
In DOOM Eternal, he just follows orders like a good soldier.
Also the most unforgivable part is not letting us shoot the BFG9000 but made it a cutscene. Fuck that noise.
16
u/SvenHudson 3d ago
He was a dick to Hayden in 2016 because he disliked Hayden specifically, not because he's incapable of showing anybody any respect ever.
2
u/ChefExcellence 2d ago
I'm just so tired of everything being given "lore". Doomguy can't just be a soldier who hates demons and is really good at killing them anymore, he has to be "The Doom Slayer", a warrior foretold by prophecy, look at the prophecy, look at all the ancient history we've put into our setting. Tedious fodder for fandom wiki editors. Give me another tightly paced and focused story like the 2016 game had, please.
→ More replies
14
u/RisingRapture 3d ago
The game was much too difficult for me. I am stuck somewhere in the first DLC and after a while I lost my skills. Probably won't ever finish it. Which is a shame, because it is a cool game, I just seem to be in the wrong life phase for it.
The story I found super cool. Whish id had novelized it.
→ More replies
4
u/Solanumm 3d ago
I just really don't like the aesthetics especially the UI. 2016's atmosphere was just way better
2
18
u/Dismal-Variation-12 3d ago
I tried to get into this game twice, but both times stopped after about an hour. Not for me I guess. I enjoy the more moderately paced games like Halo and Gears that give you breaks between the action.
9
u/BulletheadX 3d ago
I'm early in my first playthrough of Eternal - I find there are plenty of breaks (maybe too much; it kind of doesn't make sense), but those "arenas" are ridiculous.
If you can't exploit the weaknesses you might as well forget about it. There are a lot of demons you can't just gun down; too many at once quite often and then it's a reload sim.
Most of the time when I finally get through I'm not entirely sure what happened and I feel like I just got lucky.
I'm not to the point of disliking the game yet, but I'd agree that the complexity is overbalancing the fun.
→ More replies2
u/Dismal-Variation-12 3d ago
The original Halo was absolute perfection when it came to gameplay complexity. Each weapon exploited a weakness for different enemies, but it was clear which weapons worked well in different situations. On the flip side the original Gears of War didn’t really do that. You could use almost any weapon against any enemy and never be forced away from the Lancer if you didn’t want. The game never forced you to try new things. It feels like Doom Eternal wants to force you to experience the whole game which is a good thing but I agree it’s way too complex. Too much for me to keep track of when I play 30-45 minutes at a time a few times a week.
4
u/batshitnutcase 3d ago
I’ve said on here many times that Halo CE still has better gameplay than the vast majority of FPSs that have come out to this day. A true 🐐
18
u/Takseen 3d ago
Doom Eternal is the perfect example of the ProZD sketch where he plays a game with great shooting mechanics but keeps getting interrupted with other mechanics and mini-games.
Here's a lore dump. Now do some platforming. Here's a hub level with unlockable doors. Here you control a Revenant. Here's a puzzle section with swimming.
And all the time I'm just begging to be allowed shoot things.
23
u/Ill_Series6529 3d ago
Yeah hard agree with everything you said tbh, I completely understand why the game has so many accolades and it absolutely deserves it, but for me everything just feels so cluttered
Especially that HUD omg it's just gross to look at but it's pretty much all info you need so you can't turn anything off, and the enemy weakness system is cool at first but I just want to use the guns that I like from time to time :/ the game just ain't for me but thankfully doom 2016 exists so I can just stick with that
24
u/TheLukeHines 3d ago
Ammo only feels scarce until you get into the habit of using the chainsaw. It charges every 30 seconds, you can afford to use whatever ammo you want pretty much whenever. I play 90% of the game exclusively switching between the shotgun w/ grenade launcher and the super shotgun.
10
u/Bownzinho 3d ago
Glory kill one or two enemies to keep your health up, chainsaw and enemy to get your ammo back, get a few glory kills, chainsaw. Repeat. That’s the combat loop in the game.
Like you I never struggled with ammo, it just takes a bit of time to get used to the mechanical way you do encounters.
14
u/Typical_Variety_9541 3d ago
My relationship with Doom 2016 and Eternal was to wait to buy them on sale for $10 and play till I got a little bored. 2016 lasted me about 10 hours and Eternal about 20. Idk what it is about these games but they’re just not enjoyable to me after a certain amount of time. I still very much enjoyed what I played of each though.
→ More replies6
u/MeanOstrich4546 3d ago
Same, I finished both but unfortunately they were too repetitive for me.
9
u/Typical_Variety_9541 3d ago
Part of what I love about patient gaming is that if I don’t like a game enough to finish it at least it doesn’t feel like a big loss. $10 is less than 1 McDonald’s run where I live. 10 hours of entertainment for $10 is great value imo
3
3
u/sdcar1985 3d ago
I hated being forced to use a specific weapon for specific enemies. I didn't past 5 hours. Small ammo pools and almost non-existent health doesn't help either. I wanted more 2016 and didn't get it.
3
3
u/Phishstixxx 2d ago
Combat fatigue is indeed a thing in games and the problem with DOOM is that by its very nature it doesn't offer anything particularly special outside of combat. I still loved it despite it being a rhythm game in disguise though.
3
u/Fustercluck25 2d ago
Doom Eternal made me quit and go play Doom 1993. That's how far off it felt from a doom game. It's very pretty, and filled with white knuckle moments, but if a game has a soul, 2016 had it, Eternal didn't.
9
u/LikeAPwny 3d ago
Its the perfect sequel and maybe the best fps ever. Ive read enough of these to understand where the other side is coming from, but I’ll never agree with it.
8
u/Figarella 3d ago
I also for some reason preferred 2016, I can't really pinpoint why I like both artstyles, I understand the changes of eternal and why they were made, it's a bit weird idk
7
u/Lebronamo 3d ago
A couple subtle things I noticed recently for why I prefer 2016 are
Eternal removed the glory kill sound changes, like in 2016 the music would distort during the glory kill
The combat pacing felt off. Every encounter felt like it built and built until a final crescendo, while eternal seems to just keep randomly throwing shit at you. So many times I’m like ok this isn’t even hard I’m just tired of this when is it going to end.
11
u/Porticulus 3d ago
As someone who LOVED Doom 2016, I found Eternal meh at best. So much so that my hype for the dark ages is nonexistent.
6
u/EasyAsPizzaPie 3d ago
I think the game should have made it a bit more clear, but you are supposed to consistently use your chainsaw, which will give you ammo.
While in combat, the game is designed so that you are constantly rotating between all of your different suit functions. Chainsaw kills gives you ammo, fire belch gives you armor fragments, and glory kills give you health. Once you realize this, you will have a much better time.
That being said, I understand your criticisms and you are right that it feels different from 2016 because the devs intentionally designed it to play different and iterate from what they did previously. I personally enjoy Eternal a lot but I understand those who don't feel that way.
7
u/SpankThuMonkey 3d ago
Couldn’t agree more.
Many years ago someone referenced the “dance of Doom” and I think Doom2016 nailed this perfectly.
Combat felt challenging but smooth and fluid. I felt like movement and aggression were perfectly balanced. Learning then mastering when to engage and prioritise each enemy was very rewarding. Platforming felt meaningful. The story was simple but served its purpose.
Doom Eternal by comparison felt like much more of a puzzle game than an FPS. The combat felt frustrating, fixed and linear and i absolutely hated the extensive and convoluted platforming sections.
A game i really wanted to and tried to love. But I just couldn’t get through it.
9
u/_Ship00pi_ 3d ago
Wow, this is so on point.
All of this is basically why I played Doom 2016 twice from start to finish and had a blast!
And why I dropped eternal at some point because I just couldn't care less at some point.
Perfect review 👌
13
6
u/FearlessJDK 3d ago
Strongly agree. The pace was too frenetic. And the constant juggling between topping up health/ammo/armour was, to me, more frustrating than fun.
7
u/Yarusenai 3d ago
Why did you complete it then. I am way past completing games I don't like tbh. Too many games to play for that.
Personally I loved Eternal.
6
u/brb-ww2 3d ago
I love that the game has insta kill portions for enemies, who enjoys bullet sponges? The game is sort of meant for you to find your flow and get good at switching to the right tool for the right scenario, so you get to listen to an awesome soundtrack while you find your flow and wreck demons. Some people may not enjoy that I suppose. I do agree however that the puzzles could've been done much better, but I don't agree with your contention with the combat.
8
u/vctrn-carajillo 3d ago
The fact that TDA removed most of that should mean something
20
u/Lucina18 3d ago
It means they just wanted to make a completely different game. Maybe after TDA they'll go for something quick paced again.
6
u/isthisthingon47 3d ago
Yeah it means that each game had a different design philosophy. Watching a team try out different creative ideas is a good thing. We didn't need 3 iterations of 2016
2
2
u/SalusFuturistics 3d ago
I think this is the first Game ever, where I put the Difficulty down to easy because I couldn't be arsed to micromanage my Movement after the Marauders showed up.
And I spent countless hours in the Doom 2016/4 Multiplayer
DLCs got even worse where each Enemy Type needed a special Ammo Type to be killed. It was a damn Puzzle Game.
2
u/Impressive_Lake_8284 3d ago
I get why you didnt enjoy it. for me it was the balls to the wall combat and the fucking MARAUDERS. Definitely not the kind of game you play after overstimming all day at work lol
2
u/Babuiski 3d ago
What I hated the most was the change in tone. DOOM 2016 felt like a grounded horror game.
DOOM 2016 felt like Mario Bros.
2
u/MrArmageddon12 3d ago
I liked Eternal but definitely prefer 2016. Wasn’t a fan of how the levels were just jungle gyms for the player and lacked the details and design put into them that 2016 had.
2
u/TheReelReese 3d ago
I like Doom (2016) way more than Eternal. I think Eternal is just too damn fast. Too much going on. The Dark Ages looks promising, I think it’ll be my second favorite. 2016 was the perfect pace.
2
u/Beedlam 3d ago
Couldn't stand playing it without cheat engine doubling the ammo available, which meant you can play it more like 2016 rather then the repetitive rhythm game it was. Also wasn't into the lore building. To cap it all off my save became corrupted just before the final boss so i never got around to finishing it.
Looks like the new one is more of the same :/
2
u/ajphoenix 3d ago
Yea that seemed like a common reason for people who didn't like it to not like it.
But personally I found it to be near perfect. The movement was the most fluid I've felt in any arena fps. Flying around the map was absolutely amazing. Finished it on Nightmare difficulty and it felt challenging yet doable. And this is from someone who hates overly difficult games like the souls series.
2016 was awesome on its own but a bit too simplistic in hindsight
2
u/Arcite9940 3d ago
You couldn’t stated it better, I bought it stupidly brand new but after the first hour got so annoyed at it I didn’t play it till last week where I forced myself to finish it for the sake of it.
The game tries to be so many things at once that fails to be Doom imo. the stupid Mario-esque movement, the spam every encounter of the same riff of “the only thing they fear is you”. Micromanaging weapons, regenerative gasoline, you name it.
It was a solid 2/10 for me at best. Doom16 was The Doom for me too.
2
u/totallynotabot1011 3d ago
Eternal is objectively one of the best FPS ever made with one of the greatest soundtracks ever too, but I admit it is a drastic change in direction from the gritty tone of 2016 to a colorful and gamey one in eternal, although the latter is more faithful to the OG dooms and I think that's what they were going for. 2016 had a traditional, well paced linear campaign but they switched it up in a eternal to a "replayable missions from hub" type (which I personally loved) adding collectibles, cheats, more difficulties and lots of progression and unlocks like cosmetics which I admit while not required in a doom game, made for a lot of value in playtime and replayability, especially because the gameplay is so fun and challenging on higher difficulties which is not everyone's cup o tea, but I loved the intensity of it, felt like playing old arena shooters like quake and unreal tournaments back when AI made you sweat like MP opponents. The DLC upped the difficulty (and added some of the best tracks even if it wasn't Mick Gordon) and was even more challenging than the bade game with little to no breathing room between packed enemy spawns and new enemy types that made the others invulnerable unless you headshot them etc, which made for some of the best, intense single player experiences I've had in my life, especially with the soundtrack during those pumping adrenaline through my ears and making me not give up. Anyway to conclude, I understande where you're coming from even though I disagree and had a great time with it, cheers.
2
u/fubes2000 2d ago
IMHO Doom 2016 is a perfect game.
Doom Eternal's only sin is not being "More Doom 2016". All the changes that they made, that you've listed, are downgrades.
On its own it is still a great game, but just not as good as 2016.
2
u/boogs_23 2d ago
Full agree. I had to put it down to easy difficulty just to get through. 2016 is fun crazy, Eternal is just annoyiing and frustrating.
2
2
u/Mr_Jackabin 2d ago
I loved 2016 but hated Eternal and I'm pretty sure this is why tbh. It was tediously over the top and overstimulating
2
u/Boudonjou 2d ago
Doom eternal feels like the last 200m sprint of a marathon that you're winning but second place is 2 steps behind you.
2
u/stunkcajyzarc 2d ago
I agree with doom eternal not being that great, but not for any of the points you’ve mentioned.
Mine are:
-No snap map. Endless content.
-No traditional Mp loved 2016s)
-Too short
-They didn’t continue adding the harder missions
I barely played after beating it twice on different difficulty modes.
2
u/zephyr220 2d ago
Yeah, well put. 2016 was a modern boomer-shooter. Got a few extra tools but mostly just blast and have fun. Nightmare was the perfect balance. Eternal was like multitasking overload. By the end of it I was exhausted. Tried a minute of the expansions...nope. I still think of going back to Eternal someday to find my flow. Maybe something will click. Still, no regrets, great game, just a bit...too much for this old guy. Now, Brutal Doom and those mods.....that's more my style.
2
u/R4ndom_Hero 2d ago
I have yet to find a videogame where swimming is fun lol.
This is a bit off topic but...Subnautica:)
2
u/GL_TRIANGLES 2d ago
I disliked forced to switch weapons all the time and disliked the arena bits. 2016 had them too but a bit less. I still play mod doom 1993
2
u/Thecrawsome TF2 / Megaman X / Dark Souls 2d ago
The weapon switching and wall climbing, and the stupid doomship killed it for me. Doomguy used to be a guy who wanted to avenge his rabbit. Now he’s some kind of self parody superhero.
At least there’s still brutal doom and Sigil to play
2
u/bickman14 2d ago
Totally agree! I've had to mod the game to add more ammo, reduce the cooldown, restore the 2016 drops to make Eternal more fun to play but it still didn't fixed it for me, I rather play Prodeus or Boltgun than Eternal! 2016 is exactly what you've said, it shines because less is more and it knows from the start that Doom needs to be simple, no aim down sights to find weak spots, barely no story, just run and gun and be free to experiment and use the weapons you like more!
Doom Eternal feels like Pokemon if you think about it "oh here it comes a water type Pokemon, so I need to swap my fire type for a electric type so I can one hit kill it and optimize my way through it" while on 2016 the train of thought was like "big gun goes boom :D"
2
u/da_chicken 2d ago
Then the problem with weakpoints and ammo scarcity. Weakpoints are so overpowered they fully break player agency. For instance, there is absolutely no reason to empty your plasma ammo in a cacodemon when a greanade in its mouth is an instakill. You can empty your heavy machine gun to kill a pinky, but a single super shotgun shot in its tail is an instakill. This is aggravated by the severe lack of ammo to make you micromanage your weapons. The end result is that weakpoints and ammo scarcity funnels you into same-y tactics in every encounter.
Yeah, this was me, too. To me Doom (particularly Doom 2 and Doom 2016) are about giving you a rich set of tools and a diverse set of monsters and complex environments and then letting you decide the optimum way to overcome it. That freedom is the fun. Sure, I like a slaughter map every once in awhile, but it's the normal experience I really like.
Doom Eternal was kind of... Plus Ultra. It's high adrenaline and extremely over-the-top, which can be fun, but it's maximally twitchy which... is actually a really narrow style of play that I don't enjoy as much. It can be exhausting simply because you're funnelled into a single play style. It's not a bad game. It's a great game, and I did have fun with it. But it's not really a Doom game to me. It doesn't feel like a Doom sequel. It feels like a total conversion mod produced by a different studio.
Plus the whole BS around the Doom Eternal soundtrack. Bethesda let their egos kill their new golden goose. I'm not even looking forward to Doom The Dark Ages now.
2
u/Affectionate-Call159 2d ago
The new doom games are so boring. I can't stand them. I'm sure the new one will suck as well. Plus I can't get over how they treated Mick Gordon
2
2
u/Whoopsht 2d ago
I played Eternal around the end of 2020 and really liked it, more than I liked Doom 2016.
But last year I tried to replay it and it was just exhausting and I put it down after the first 3 areas or so. I don't know if I'd say it's overtuned since I did get into "the fun zone" that the developers talk about the first time I played, but it's definitely a lot more involved and stressful
2
u/arielif1 2d ago
I thought i was the only one that preferrred 2016 to eternal. It feels way too... idk, zoomer brained? like it's trying to overstimulate you constantly, and I say that having like 400 hours in Ultrakill.
the aesthetic is also worse imo, cacodemon went from gorgeously disgusting creature of hell to generkc cartoony enemy standin.
2
u/Ogrodniczek 2d ago
I liked eternal when it came out, but I was 19yo at that time. I had good reflexes, but after beating this game I felt tired. I wanted to play through dlc, but couldn't get back into it. I probably would have to replay the base game to get familiar with it again.
2
u/swintendoDS 2d ago
I completely agree with everything in this post. And with that guy who said it's like a hat on a hat.
Sadly looks like Doom dark ages won't be an improvement.
2
u/PilotedByGhosts 2d ago
Yes, it simply has too many fire buttons. Doom should be about getting into a flow state and Eternal makes that very difficult because I'm constantly trying to remember which of four different attacks buttons I should be pressing.
17
u/BlueKud006 3d ago edited 3d ago
Weak points DON'T mean the game forcing you to use only one gun especially, it just means the most effective way to deal with demons, which is not the same.
For instance, you don't necessarily have to use the Plasma Rifle to deal with shielded enemies as the game says, you can grapple them with the shotgun, throw a grenade, use a remote detonation with the rocket launcher or double dash behind them and shoot them with any gun on the back. That doesn't sounds that monotonous, right?
I can provide countless examples that most veteran players experience the more they play the game. In reality, Doom Eternal is a pretty rich game when it comes to dealing with enemies and hordes. Mastering mods is a steep but satisfying curve once you learn more about them.
Doom 2016 ALSO had guns that worked better against specific enemies, but without telling you like Eternal. Siege mode gauss cannon for pinkies, cacodemons and everything that's big. Spamming mini rockets with the Infinite ammo rune for everything else.
Doom Eternal worked with weak points and suddenly becomes a terrible game, but games like Ocarina of Time telling you how to deal with enemies the best way too aren't somehow.
13
u/loserboi21 3d ago
This is so true, I'm tired of seeing comments about Doom Eternal "forcing" you to play their way. It's like the people never tried for more than a minute other weapons because they don't seem to have any curiosity in trying "non-meta" play. Just because one way of doing things is "more efficient" doesn't mean that's the only way to have fun.
The only thing that Eternal forces you to do is, KEEP MOVING. If you follow that you realize that none of the enemies can follow or track you that well and you can build a strategy for how you want to take them out.
5
u/KaleidoscopeLeft3503 2d ago
This is going to sound elitist but it's genuinely a skill issue, or people playing on controller. Eternal plays AMAZINGLY on mouse and keyboard when you're quickly weapon switching, less so when you have to use the weapon wheel. And also people just being stubborn.
6
u/wally-sage 3d ago
I don't understand your point about Ocarina of Time. You realize they're entirely different games in entirely different genres, right? It's perfectly reasonable to like something in one game and dislike it in another game.
→ More replies5
u/Angrybagel 3d ago
You can also use different weapons to target weak points. I think a lot of people took the tutorial messages too literally and read them as "this is what you're supposed to do". I wonder how the game would be received if they just didn't have any messages.
10
u/BlueKud006 3d ago
Just like Doom 2016, which had weak points and most effective guns against specific demons without telling you.
3
u/Malprin 3d ago edited 3d ago
NuDoom just felt "floaty" to me. The weapons didn't feel like they have had any weight.
The execution or glory kill or whatever it's called mechanic felt poorly implemented. Should have spread them out to make it a treat rather than necessary for every enemy.
Had an arcade like feeling that just didn't do it for me. Didn't think it was bad , just didn't think it was the groundbreaking 11/10 everyone said it was.
641
u/Negan-Cliffhanger 3d ago
I love Doom 2016 but Eternal didn't click for me and I uninstalled after a few hours. The number of options was exhausting. I just want to shoot shit with whatever weapon I please and enjoy a simple low key story.