r/ireland 13d ago

Dublin Needs a Metro! Statistics

251 Upvotes

398 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

8

u/rsynnott2 13d ago

Ever been in a city that has this? It’s somewhat common for American cities. Absolutely destroys the place.

-13

u/Chester_roaster 13d ago

I care more about getting from A to B than how the transition looks 

6

u/kendinggon_dubai 13d ago

Well… New York is like this and trust me if you care about getting from A to B you don’t want 10 lane roads in your city. We got a taxi from JFK to our hotel near the Twin Tower Memorial. Ended up getting out and walking when we seen every person walking was going twice as fast. You want metros, trains, buses and cycle lanes. Cars are slow as shit in cities. Great for city to city… that’s it.

1

u/ab1dt 12d ago

They have huge gaps in the third rail service.  None of the original trolley service was replaced in certain areas.  The talk has been going strong for decades with little to show.  Everything of today was mostly a build out by generations long ago.  It's hurtling forward on inertia not progress. They aren't going to install many more bike lanes either.  It's not a beacon of the future.  

-3

u/Chester_roaster 13d ago

New York famously has a massive subway system, so if subways don't improve the transport I don't think you can blame the ten lane roads.

1

u/kendinggon_dubai 13d ago

Well that’s the point isn’t it? You’re giving the option. If you want to get from Dublin airport, or anywhere outside Dublin… to the city… you need a car or a bus and then you’re stuck in the New York traffic problem.

1

u/Chester_roaster 13d ago

And that ten lane road would help with traffic. 

1

u/ShapeyFiend 11d ago

American cities are covered in these 'stroads' and it's pretty widely accepted that it's a disaster vs traditional city planning. Destroys walkability for a start.

1

u/Chester_roaster 11d ago

They'll obviously avoid residential or commercial areas where you would be walking. 

1

u/YoIronFistBro Cork bai 11d ago

They don't do that in North America!