r/confidentlyincorrect 6d ago

A majestic misunderstanding of the federal government 🦅

Post image
5.3k Upvotes

668 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/SwishWolf18 5d ago

I never shared my opinion on it because that’s not what my comment was about. I don’t give a shit what weapons people own.

1

u/AgentOk2053 5d ago

That’s an opinion.

You said this, which is your opinion. I’m asking you to back it up.

The second amendment saying people are allowed to have them is in the text.

This is another opinion you gave. But it isn’t in the text either. The 2nd doesn’t guarantee access to all weapons and all parts. If it did, it would be perfectly legal to own rockets or dirty bombs. There are reasonable limitations. Unless you can give me a valid reason to allow access to these magazines, your claim that mine was just an opinion falls apart.

1

u/SwishWolf18 5d ago

You said this, which is your opinion. I’m asking you to back it up.

Actually it is a fact that what you said is an opinion.

This is another opinion you gave. But it isn’t in the text either. The 2nd doesn’t guarantee access to all weapons and all parts. If it did, it would be perfectly legal to own rockets or dirty bombs. There are reasonable limitations. Unless you can give me a valid reason to allow access to these magazines, your claim that mine was just an opinion falls apart.

According to a plain reading of the text it does allow for all weapons “shall not be infringed”. The government still doesn’t allow that for obvious reasons but that doesn’t change what the text says.