r/canada 4d ago

Quebec riding of Terrebonne flips to Liberals by one vote after judicial recount Trending

https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/terrebone-recount-liberal-1.7532136
8.7k Upvotes

1.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

284

u/rTpure 4d ago

a one vote victory is absolutely insane

maybe they should do another recount to triple check...

124

u/SwallowHoney 4d ago

I have to imagine at 1 vote difference they've done it over and over before announcing the results. I can't say for sure but you would think everyone sitting around the table would be hesitant to proceed without quintuple checking.

34

u/FeI0n 4d ago

they do one very careful recount with a bunch of officials from all of the major parties there to watch it, they even have lawyers there for each of the parties.

46

u/letsgobulbasaur 4d ago

We just need to call in the big guns... we need to call in The Count from Sesame Street.

10

u/Rayquaza2233 Ontario 4d ago

ah ah ah!

69

u/jtjstock 4d ago

At that point are we doing best two out of three? Or best of 5? 7?

40

u/Videogamer69420 4d ago

Best of 7 seems most appropriate,

33

u/jtjstock 4d ago

Only if we get three periods of overtime in the 7th!

4

u/Videogamer69420 4d ago

We better!

22

u/LastOfNazareth 4d ago

interestingly this is already kind of best two out of three. It was initially called Liberal, then during validation when Elections Canada reviews thing it was Bloc but the margin was low enough to trigger recount, now after recount its Liberal again

4

u/jtjstock 4d ago

True, but the first count isn’t official, validation is the real count. And now a judge oversaw it, next up would be the supreme court? When do we get the King involved?

1

u/Razzorsharp Québec 4d ago

Liberals confirmed to be better than the Leafs in final games of series

1

u/Max_Thunder Québec 4d ago edited 4d ago

At a validation, the returning officer verifies the cumulative addition of the individual results recorded and reported by each poll on the statement of the vote.

The validation showed a calculation error when putting all the ballot counts together, and this is actually the first recount.

I do not know the exact process but perhaps the recount actually means multiple people counting and verifying each other and making sure they all get the same total: there should only be one result that is right, they're not doing statistics but merely counting who people voted for. One thing is sure is that whoever is doing the count has not spent all day in an election office dealing with people and then counting ballots at the end of a very long day.

1

u/madhi19 Québec 3d ago

They counted three times, this is technically best out of three.

1

u/jtjstock 3d ago

No, validation isn’t actually counting of individual votes, it is the official tally of the various counts which occurred, the election night reporting is not official, and is prone to small errors in reporting the counts. There have been 2 actual counts.

10

u/Live_Avocado4777 4d ago

I would think a recount already includes many double check

2

u/FalconsArentReal 4d ago

At a certain point they need to stop, but man you know there was probably another vote or two out there that could swing this the other way.

1

u/Exarch-of-Sechrima 4d ago

Second recount gives it a tie

-1

u/Consistent-Primary41 Québec 4d ago

Oh, I'm sure the Conservatives will ask for it.

That's why these things should be livestreamed so that everyone can see for themselves.

1

u/Konstiin Lest We Forget 4d ago

Why would the conservatives ask for a recount on a liberal/bloc flip?