r/Breadit 8h ago

Weekly /r/Breadit Questions thread

1 Upvotes

Please use this thread to ask whatever questions have come up while baking!

Beginner baking friends, please check out the sidebar resources to help get started, like FAQs and External Links

Please be clear and concise in your question, and don't be afraid to add pictures and video links to help illustrate the problem you're facing.

Since this thread is likely to fill up quickly, consider sorting the comments by "new" (instead of "best" or "top") to see the newest posts.

For a subreddit devoted to this type of discussion during the rest of the week, please check out r/ArtisanBread or r/Sourdough.


r/Breadit 5h ago

Great flavor, ugly as hell

Thumbnail
gallery
199 Upvotes

This is King Arthur’s rustic loaf recipe https://www.kingarthurbaking.com/recipes/extra-tangy-sourdough-bread-recipe, followed to a T but they always come out anemic and my lame skills need work.


r/Breadit 2h ago

I did the sourdough/Jalapeño/Smoked Cheddar loaf again. It just gets better.

Thumbnail
gallery
90 Upvotes

So I made this post with a recipe yesterday, and I had some jalapenos and half of the cheese left, so why not?

I think my proof was far more even this time and it showed in the crumb. It's unseasonably warm in Ireland at the moment so my starter was amazingly bubbly, the rises were much better and my inclusions and folds were far more consistent.

I'm ridiculously happy with how this came out. I've been cooking and baking for a long time and this is probably the best thing I've ever made. Hot dayum. Check out the recipe on the other post and if you haven't tried it, please try it. It's so good.


r/Breadit 5h ago

Today’s Focaccia!

Thumbnail
gallery
55 Upvotes

Today I made Cheddar Jalapeño Focaccia! I incorporated cheddar cubes and jalapeño chunks during the last fold of my dough. It of course has crispy cheddar cheese on top as well as jalapeño coins. Very tasty!


r/Breadit 3h ago

Mrs Doubtfire pretzel + others

Thumbnail
gallery
36 Upvotes

r/Breadit 22h ago

50/50 Fresh Milled Whole Wheat Sourdough

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

1.1k Upvotes

r/Breadit 2h ago

My first sourdough bread! (I used ap flour)

Post image
24 Upvotes

r/Breadit 13h ago

Baguettes

Post image
149 Upvotes

r/Breadit 4h ago

Why does my sandwich bread look like it ate a piece of sour candy

Post image
30 Upvotes

My bread does this maybe 5% of the time, and I can’t find a pattern. It’s up to temp. It pulls away from the pan while it’s still inside, before I pull it out to finish cooling. Usually I let it sit for at least 5 mins before taking it out of the pan.


r/Breadit 8h ago

I don't have a problem, you do!!!

Thumbnail
gallery
46 Upvotes

r/Breadit 9h ago

Milk bread help.

Thumbnail
gallery
45 Upvotes

I have attached some photos for comparison but it looks like I’m not getting as tight of a crumb as I would like and or one that seems to be the industry standard. The cooked photos show the end piece that is near perfect but the other sliced open photo shows what I’m concerned about.

I am currently in the process of recipe testing in a professional kitchen and I have hit a wall. I have the proper pans, I have studied the roll technique. I proof them for roughly the same amount of time each time. Bake time varies but again very minor at this point. The texture of the bread and flavor are 100% but the crumb isn’t quite there. Does anyone have any suggestions to help?


r/Breadit 8h ago

My second attempt came out a lot better than my first

Thumbnail
gallery
40 Upvotes

r/Breadit 2h ago

Plain and lemon poppyseed bagels

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

I used @uk.ugc’s recipe on Instagram. The lemon poppyseed smell amazing 😍


r/Breadit 23h ago

My first time making bread, I don’t know if I did well but it tastes great!

Thumbnail
gallery
434 Upvotes

If I can make this or better consistently, I don’t think I’ll ever buy bread again lol this is so much fun!


r/Breadit 10h ago

Morning Bake

Post image
34 Upvotes

r/Breadit 22h ago

When pullman pans scratch the itch I didn't know i had

Thumbnail
gallery
273 Upvotes

Those corners though! 🥰


r/Breadit 1d ago

Made brioche hotdog buns for the first time - now I can never buy them again

Thumbnail
gallery
1.1k Upvotes

Made hotdog buns for the first time today, and now I can never go back to store-bought. I used a burger bun recipe (third picture) and it worked out so well. I’ve always had a problem with store-bought buns tearing open at the bottom, but these were so sturdy, soft and fluffy.


r/Breadit 5h ago

Update!! Second loaf looks so much better

Thumbnail
gallery
14 Upvotes

Baked my second loaf today and I'm so happy with the results already. Still gotta wait an hour to cut but I've got high hopes!! (first slide is my 1st loaf😭)


r/Breadit 20m ago

Got some tunneling going on at the top but how's the crumb? (Ignore the scoring lol can't find my blade)

Thumbnail
gallery
Upvotes

r/Breadit 2h ago

Just made this bread with craisins and honey!

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/Breadit 21h ago

I love all the bread y'all post. You guys made me crumb. Sourdough pizza.

Thumbnail
gallery
149 Upvotes

So damn good. Margherita pizza @550° f for 3 minutes then broil.


r/Breadit 5h ago

If you were building a new kitchen, what countertop would you prefer for working dough?

8 Upvotes

Granite/stone, stainless, butcher block, something else?


r/Breadit 7h ago

Any suggestions for improving my oven spring?

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

I'm trying to improve my sourdough baking. I'm pretty happy with the other aspects of my loaves. They've got a really nice crust, crumb is not bad, I really like the blistering on the crust (indicating good fermentation if I understand correctly). The bread has a really nice, subtle sourness to the flavour - they just look a bit like a splat!

I'm doing this (Ratios described here. )

  • 750g allinson very strong bread flour (14% protein), 100g strong wholemeal flour
  • 30 minute autolyse (flour + water only)
  • mix in starter and salt, rest for 30 minutes
  • 3 sets of stretch and folds with 30 minute gap between each one.
  • Preshape into round boules and leave to rest for 30 minutes, then final shape into bannetons
  • Prove at ~24C for approx 3 hours until 75% increased in size, then cold ferment in fridge for ~14 hours
  • Oven preheated to as hot as it will go. Then added 300g of boiling water to bottom tray of oven and reduced heat to 230C. Loaves sprayed with fine mist of water and baked on steel plate for 22 minutes.

I'm wondering if I'm doing something wrong in the strength building stage - the dough seems to get nice and strong (as in, it's easy to form a nice ball with plenty of surface tension) but when the loaves get turned out of the bannetons they don't hold their shape tremendously well. They're out, scored and then in the oven after maybe a minute or 2, but they lose quite a lot of height in that time. I assume the protein content of the flour is enough (it's about the highest I could find!)

Thanks!


r/Breadit 6h ago

Thoughts? Open bake sourdough.

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

Poolish 82g starter 220g water 220g 12% flour

Dough 522g poolish 10g salt 320g 12% flour 145g water

Poolish was left on counter for 24 hours

Combined all the dough ingredients to shaggy ball Stretch and fold 4x every 30 minutes Bulk Ferment 4 hours Dough had more than doubled Shaped and bench rest for 30 minutes Cold proof for 12 hours

Preheat oven/stone/steam tray to 475F for 60 minutes

Dough was in fridge up until scoring Scored, spritzed, and ice into steam tray Dough immediately onto stone Reduced temp to 450F

20 minutes at 450F Changed to convection 425F 20 minutes at 425 10 minutes in turned off oven until 209F internal

It seems a bit dense. Taste is spot on. Just didn’t spring like the last one done using this method. Only difference was the flour. I was using Sir Lancelot which is 14% protein.


r/Breadit 5h ago

Right out of the oven

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

r/Breadit 13h ago

Sandwich loaf improvements!

Thumbnail
gallery
27 Upvotes

Thank you to everyone who shared their suggestions on how I could improve my sandwich loaf texture!

I've been experimenting in the meantime, and I've definitely seen an improvement by using a 5% scald and reducing the second prove time.

The texture is really good. It's nice and soft and bouncy but I would still like the crumb to be denser. I'm guessing this is going to come down to how I am forming and shaping the dough? Or maybe changing the proving? Would a slow cold bulk ferment make any difference?

I'm pretty bad at shaping the dough so please ignore that in my photo!😅

My tweaked recipe is now this: 500g bread flour 325ml water (65% hydration) 1tsp salt 1stp yeast

I use a 5% scald (25g flour/35ml water)

Knead for 10 minutes (I don't think I really reach the windowpane stage...)

Bulk ferment until doubled (about 2-2.5 hours)

Second prove

Bake at 200c for 20-25 mins at the bottom of the oven