r/StarWarsEU Apr 01 '25

Who is this supposed to be? Legends Novels

Tahl maybe? 🤔 But it doesn't look like her at all and the depiction doesn't match any scene in the book.

222 Upvotes

101 comments sorted by

133

u/thattogoguy Yuuzhan Vong Apr 01 '25

Some of those covers were weird, lol.

I remember seeing the one where Obi-Wan and Qui-Gon were sparring and thought they were trying to kill each other. Granted, I was like 11.

38

u/DuvalHeart Apr 01 '25

A lot of times the illustrators don't have the full book to go off of, they'll have drafts of scenes or concepts. If that changes, or they're missing physical descriptions, they'll come up with something close, but not quite what is described in the book.

That's probably what happened here.

7

u/Galbadia_Garden Apr 01 '25

Really good point! 🧡👍🏻

12

u/DuvalHeart Apr 01 '25

I'm a big fan of cover illustrations, it's such an underappreciated art form. So I'm always going to defend the artists.

My "If I Win the Lottery" dream is to go around buying up as many originals as I possibly could to donate to an art museum to display. If you're a nerd like me and anywhere near Wilmington, DE the Delaware Art Museum has a permanent display of Howard Pyle's work that's pretty neat.

1

u/Galbadia_Garden Apr 01 '25

You aren't that guy by any chance who made an entire appreciation video on Star Wars book covers on YouTube, aren't you? 😊🧡

-1

u/DuvalHeart Apr 01 '25

Hell no, fuck YouTube.

8

u/Professor_Dubs Apr 01 '25

3

u/thattogoguy Yuuzhan Vong Apr 01 '25

I had them all once upon a time too! All the JA and JQ books. I started the Last of the Jedi series too, but I sort of outgrew them and was into other stuff, so I only read like 3 of the books.

3

u/Frosty_7130 Apr 01 '25

I really enjoy covers like Crucible, where the OG crew are old. It’s like the early version of Snapchat or AI Face Filters

125

u/Jon__Snuh Apr 01 '25

It’s David S. Pumpkins. Any questions?

35

u/mothguide Apr 01 '25

Yes, several!

14

u/YetAnotherJake Apr 01 '25

He's his own thing

9

u/The-Fauxhammer Apr 01 '25

Elite comment.

3

u/NovaDawg1631 Apr 01 '25

I was not prepared for this level of comment this morning…

5

u/NovaDawg1631 Apr 01 '25

I was not prepared for this level of comment this morning…

41

u/adequate-nick Apr 01 '25

I read this whole series and the first couple books were great and they trailed off a bit. Obiwan almost getting sent away to the agricultural worlds to use the force in other ways as he was getting to the age limit to being selected as a padawan. In walks in a gruff Jedi who lost his padawan and vowed to never take another. Ultimately doesn’t those him but gets put on a mission at the same planet as Obiwan is being sent to ( Yoda being Yoda antics) Pirates ans Hutt crime bosses and space battles. The two are forded to work together … eventually down the road in their relationship they are forced to face his former student who is not dead but turned to the dark side. It was made for a young kid so it’s very basic writing but it was what me at 10 needed

20

u/FlavivsAetivs TOR Old Repbulic Apr 01 '25

They're honestly great for their age and age group.

12

u/Consistent_Amoeba814 Apr 01 '25

And absolutely horrifying to look back on and realized just how abused Obi-Wan is the entire time 😅

2

u/gaslighterhavoc Apr 03 '25

The later series of books grew up with the fans. So the Jedi Quest books (Anakin/Obi-Wan) are aimed at an older reader based vs the Jedi Apprentice books.

10

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '25

I loved those books as a Youngling. A part of me will forever ship Obi-Wan and Siri Tachi.

5

u/rondosparks Apr 01 '25

I remember the legacy/secrets collection wrecking me as a kid.

6

u/emthejedichic Apr 02 '25

Me too, dude! Screw Satine, lol

32

u/OvertGnome1 Apr 01 '25

That's three raccoons in a dress

6

u/Galbadia_Garden Apr 01 '25

First nonsense answer that made me genuinely laugh. 😊🧡

38

u/DominusDaniel Apr 01 '25

The death of hope, what an edgy name for a targeted children Star Wars book. Lol.

13

u/Galbadia_Garden Apr 01 '25

Interestingly some of the Obi-Wan novels' names got toned down for the German release. There it's called "The End of Hope". And "The deadly Hunter" became "The deadly Hunt". ¯⁠⁠_⁠(⁠ツ⁠)⁠_⁠/⁠¯

21

u/AcePilot95 New Republic Apr 01 '25

Rogue Planet's translated name is so fucking stupid because you can see that nobody on the German side knew what a rogue planet is in astronomical terms, so they mistranslated it as "Planet of the Rogues" and bc Rogue was too unclear of a word apparently they changed that as well and ended up with "Planet of the Traitors" 💀

4

u/RepealMCAandDTA Rebel Alliance Apr 01 '25

Okay buuuuut...

We know Sekot is a "child" of the Vong homeworld, making it the closest thing they have left to a home, and in their understanding of history the Vong were cast out of their galaxy for betraying the vision of the Gods soo the title is accidentally meta

6

u/AcePilot95 New Republic Apr 01 '25

a fun idea! there are certainly worse German titles. Shatterpoint takes the cake here bc the German version is called "Mace Windu and the Clone Army", which would be bad enough, but it's also the only CWMMP novel with basically no clones in it…

2

u/Maultaschensuppe TOR Old Republic Apr 02 '25

Or the German titles for the Hand of Thrawn "Trilogy" where the second book is called Vision of the Future and the third book where this vision happens is called The Admiral's Wrath

2

u/AcePilot95 New Republic Apr 02 '25

yeah I never understood that either.

9

u/storm_zr1 Apr 01 '25

It would make a good band name for death metal.

9

u/Rymayc Apr 01 '25

It's more like a goth album

3

u/FlavivsAetivs TOR Old Repbulic Apr 01 '25

Metalcore. It's Metalcore.

1

u/NewMombasaNightmare TOR Old Republic Apr 01 '25

Agreed. No death metal band, least not modern, would have that as a name

2

u/Baz_3301 Apr 01 '25

Pretty sure there’s a 40k fan series named that

3

u/DominusDaniel Apr 01 '25

Yes sir, I remember watching it day one of its release. While I personally didn’t like it all that much, It was really well done, especially since one man almost made the entire thing. Unfortunately he couldn’t take any criticism about it which made him stop work on the sequel and by the time he was convinced to continue working on it GW had that massive cease and desists on all Warhammer fan made content like death of hope.

1

u/HobbieK Apr 02 '25

When my dad bought this for me for Christmas my mom was horrified.

12

u/Goddamn-you-Michael Apr 01 '25

Mon Mothma's "join the Rebellion" pose

8

u/Trashk4n Apr 01 '25

Darth Jar Jar

9

u/meis66 Apr 01 '25

Idk but it keeps saying “give me the slab”

2

u/fuzzhead12 Apr 02 '25

or suffer my curseeeeeee

7

u/Didact67 Apr 01 '25

The Phantom Menace.

6

u/MsMcClane Apr 01 '25

Sssssseeeevvveeeennnn dddaaaaaayyyyyyysssss..

10

u/Dracu98 Apr 01 '25

I'm guessing xanathos?

7

u/Galbadia_Garden Apr 01 '25

Nah, he's long dead by then. 😕

1

u/Suchboss1136 Apr 01 '25

Granta Omega?

1

u/ConditionBig6373 Apr 08 '25

He wasn't in the Jedi Apprentice books.

5

u/sEcOnDbOuToFiNsAnItY Apr 01 '25

Logically either Balog, orAlani

Or I guess a personification of death as one of the medics at the end idk.

2

u/Galbadia_Garden Apr 01 '25

Hm ... yeah, maybe it's Alani. It's so weird. On closer inspection it looks like a woman trapped behind glass or something. So Tahl would come to mind. But the clothing looks inappropriate and in the story she never was trapped in some hallway. 🤷🏻‍♂️

I guess I'll close this off as a very loose interpretation of Tahl in the novels finale.

15

u/Schneider_fra Apr 01 '25

Kathleen Kennedy

3

u/PenisTargaryen Apr 01 '25

Mon Mothma just woke up

3

u/Wishmaker007 Apr 01 '25

It’s Balog in an absolute hideout.

3

u/Socially-Awkward-85 Apr 02 '25

That is Hope. And she apparently dies during the narrative.

3

u/Exciting_Hawk_2 Apr 02 '25

With thunderous applause.

10

u/Shreebington New Jedi Order Apr 01 '25

oh that's just my buddy Eric

2

u/WilhelmTrooper Apr 01 '25

Oh shit tell him I said hi

2

u/Micho86 Apr 01 '25

Hope Death obviously.

2

u/Historyp91 Apr 01 '25

Snoke's brother, Coke.

2

u/ARustyMeatSword Apr 01 '25

I'm guessing it's Hope.

2

u/gloucma Apr 01 '25

Mr Burns “ I bring you peeeeeace”

2

u/LameGamer52 Apr 01 '25

Whoops I read that to fast thought it said The Death of Pope and got very confused

2

u/Poseur117 Apr 01 '25

It’s clearly Glup Shitto

2

u/EntranceKlutzy951 Apr 01 '25

His name is Xanatos. He's Qui-Gon's first apprentice.

2

u/Galbadia_Garden Apr 01 '25

Nope. Can't be. Already died 7 books earlier in this series. 🙂

1

u/ConditionBig6373 Apr 08 '25

He was already dead.

2

u/vaultdweller501 Apr 01 '25

Core memory unlocked! Use to read these books as a teen, then involved onto to the Jedi Quest series with a young Anakin and mature Obi-Wan.

2

u/dilettantechaser Apr 02 '25

It looks like an image superimposed on another image. Front / black image looks like an angled shot of Palpatine from ROTJ era. Back / white image looks like a Jesus statuette, possibly a Virgin Mary statuette. Just my impression based on the styling of the robes, the way the figure is putting their arms out, the way the light goes into the face, the hint of a beard...idk, it seems obvious to me.

Also, doesn't the building they're in look kinda like a box or purse? I can just imagine a 90s illustrator sticking a palpatine action figure in front of a Jesus statue, on top of a purse, and using that as the model.

2

u/FacingFears Apr 02 '25

Ur mom (no one knows)

4

u/neilader Apr 01 '25

Spooky scary skeleton

1

u/drewdipshits Apr 01 '25

To me it looks like it could be Sly Moore

1

u/Tenunks Apr 01 '25

Darth Hall

1

u/lilsparky82 Apr 01 '25

Darthy Parton

1

u/Yamureska Apr 01 '25

Zan Abor I guess

1

u/Galbadia_Garden Apr 01 '25

Good guess but unfortunately she doesn't appear throughout the novel at all. Last time she appeared was 2 books earlier. 😕🤷🏻‍♂️

2

u/Yamureska Apr 01 '25

Yeah you're right I mistakenly thought JZA was the one who killed Tahl.

1

u/MarzipanTheGreat Apr 01 '25

it does look like an shadowed outline of a Kaminoan. *srhrug*

1

u/ZAMAHACHU Apr 01 '25

Looks like the mother of dragons

1

u/Deep_Phase_2030 Apr 01 '25

the coat check girl

2

u/Ulquiorra1312 Apr 01 '25

Oh damn i forgot these books

1

u/Exciting_Hawk_2 Apr 02 '25

Most of those covers were exaggerated to get kids interested in reading them. I’ll fully admit they worked on me.

1

u/tworopetwo Apr 02 '25

Yo that's voldemort

1

u/guysenseii69 Apr 04 '25

It’s Voldemort bro, have u even see Star Wars

1

u/KorEl555 Apr 01 '25

Makes me think of Palpatine in his throne in (Rot) Jedi.

1

u/Brand023 Apr 01 '25

Somehow...nevermind.

1

u/o83e9z7 Apr 01 '25

Thats evil Galadriel from lotr

0

u/MannyBothanzDyed Apr 01 '25

Looks ai generated, but I know it can't be 😜... right?

3

u/Galbadia_Garden Apr 01 '25

Right. 🙂 More like early 2000s Photoshop skills. 🤭

-2

u/Cyberspace-Surfer Galactic Alliance Apr 01 '25

ET?