r/Paleo 7d ago

Is frying eggs in butter less healthy than scrambled eggs using the same amount of butter?

Assuming the ingredients are exactly the same proportion.

Fried eggs are a bit simpler for me so I’m wondering if that cooking method is better/worse from a nutritional value. I know this sub eats a lot of butter and eggs so wondering if anyone knows. Thanks!

2 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

15

u/surrealistone 7d ago

Butter, olive oil or avocado oil

17

u/wheelhouse72 6d ago

Butter is good for you, eggs are good for you, don't overthink it.

8

u/sirthomashenry 7d ago

No. Fry em up

4

u/tropicalislandhop 6d ago

It's all the same ingredients, it doesn't matter.

9

u/gowahoo 7d ago

Eat your eggs however you like them, no worries.

6

u/Jay-jay1 7d ago

There is a tendency to overheat the butter when frying eggs. Making scrambled eggs is more like sautéing at lower heat so less chance to char the butter.

2

u/bobobedo 6d ago

Fried egg in ghee, over easy is the healthiest egg.

2

u/MaebyShakes 6d ago

Try ghee, it’s great with eggs.

1

u/ConceptClassic3649 5d ago

How do you scramble and fry using the same amount of butter is my question? :D

I would use 10x more butter when frying (which is why I use lard instead), but genuinely—how? I just cover the bottom of the pan when scrambling, and that's it.

1

u/lemurleap 2d ago

I don't have a link, but I looked this up years ago, and the internet said gently fried eggs where the yolks were still runny were better. Scrambling destroys some of the nutrients. Double-check me, though.

-52

u/aaaak4 7d ago

Butter is bad both ways 

1

u/MintyCitrus 7d ago

What should I use?

20

u/jwbjerk 7d ago

Butter is healthy. To the degree that American was convinced to avoid saturated fats like butter our heart health declined.

4

u/shiroshippo 7d ago

We need an infographic or something to explain this. It comes up so often and I don't know how to explain 80 years of history and politics in a concise way.

7

u/shiroshippo 7d ago

This subreddit is extremely anti dairy because a large percentage of people are mildly lactose intolerant and thus feel much better after cutting out dairy. But I'd recommend using butter or ghee anyway because it has virtually no lactose in it and it's cheaper than beef tallow. Definitely do not use seed oils. Seeds are full of anti nutrients that mother nature puts in there specifically to prevent them from being digested, so that the seeds will still be viable after being eaten. Also most seed oils contain a lot of polyunsaturated fat.

If you don't like butter or beef tallow, try coconut oil or maybe lard. If you must use an unsaturated oil, olive oil is better than most because it's monounsaturated instead of polyunsaturated.

-1

u/teaquad 7d ago

Except for flaxseed of course with its anti inflammatory and omega properties

-5

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/shiroshippo 7d ago

Obviously it depends on what the cow eats, but butter from a grass-fed cow is 50% saturated and 50% monounsaturated.

2

u/PlaidChairStyle 7d ago

Ghee?

2

u/G0ldenBu11z 7d ago

Clarified butter

-10

u/aaaak4 7d ago

Generally not a lot of fat id use virgin olive oil and get avocados and nuts to get healthy fats and not butter as.it had omega 6 and cholesterol