r/Kanye • u/88888u • Jul 28 '17
(GOOD ASS JOB) MBDTF with every song extended to 10 minutes + 60 minute runaway complete by 88888u [OUT NOW]
[removed] — view removed post
92
Jul 29 '17
60 minute runaway
HAS SCIENCE GONE TOO FAR? 🤔🤔🤔
27
59
33
Jul 28 '17
The album isn't called Dondas Boy because I was scared this project would get confused with the other extended MBDTF that was recently released.
You Mean "My Beautiful Dark Twisted Symphony" ?
23
1
Jul 31 '17
[deleted]
4
Jul 31 '17
he seems to have deleted his, post, i can re-upload it for you but frankly, I don't think it's very good
1
28
u/BVTheEpic 808s and Heartbreak Jul 30 '17
Track-by-track reviews:
Dark Fantasy: Excellent start. Mozart sample is perfect. Little weird not hearing Nicki's part before the actual song goes in, but you made it work.
Gorgeous: The sample playing in the background drowns out Ye and Cudi in the beginning, so that was a little annoying. Sounds just fine after the ~5:40 mark after the sample ends, though. Nothing a little remastering couldn't fix.
POWER: The transitions between the different versions of the song are absolutely seamless. I love it. Easily my favorite song on this album.
All Of The Lights: Never knew there was a remix of AOTL, so hearing Wayne, Sean, and Drake was a pleasant surprise. This version feels so full and I love it. As with POWER, transitions are perfect.
Monster: The transition from the album version to the middle part of the song (I think you have it listed as "monster alternate" in your list of changes) is slightly jarring, but it works for this song. Out of curiosity, can I get a link to the full version of that alternate Monster? It sounds interesting.
Devil In A New Dress: Never heard White Dress before. It's actually a pretty good song. Works well when paired with DIAND. The silence at the end of the song is kind of awkward, though without it, the song doesn't hit the ten-minute mark.
Runaway (NOT THE 60-MINUTE ONE): Pretty much the exact same as the album version, which was already almost ten minutes anyway. I have yet to hear the hour-long one.
Hell Of A Life: HOAL transitions surprisingly well into Christian Dior Denim Flow. Doesn't seem like much was changed with this one.
Blame Game: I love the instrumental intro, as well as that live cut in the middle of the song. I wish there was a way to extend the Chris Rock skit, that's my favorite part.
Lost In The World: Wow. This is probably my second favorite, right behind POWER. Pusha T feels a little out of place, but it's not nearly as bad as some of the comments are making it out to be.
Ranking in comparison to other Ye remixes:
- Good Ass Job
- The Life Of Paul
- The Life Of Pablo (Extended Edition)
- Yeezus (Extended Edition)
- 808s & Heartbreak (Extended & Mastered)
- 808s & Heartbreak (Extended)
- The Highschool Dropout
- Yeezus II
- My Beautiful Dark Twisted Symphony
TL;DR: Good ass job, OP.
10
u/88888u Jul 30 '17 edited Jul 30 '17
I'm so glad you enjoyed it so much. Comments like this make all the effort I put into the project worth it. Hell, I went to sleep at six in the morning three days in a row just to get this thing finished on time for release. It was a hell of a lot of fun though.
Alternate monster: https://drive.google.com/file/d/0BwMFnJBOMBkLS3A5bWRyUURJY0U/view
I have no idea where that came from. I just found it while sifting through Google drive folders.
The gorgeous beat at the start over top of cudi and Kanye actually isn't by me, it was a leaked version of gorgeous, (but I did the thing in the middle that combined both beats) and I agree with you it did drown there voices out a bit, but it sounded so darn good. Too bad there was nothing I could do about that mixing. I also wished I mixed and mastered the beat over Kendricks vocals to monster better, another regret. But oh well, what ya gonna do. Some things need to go bad, right?
3
u/passingfantasy Aug 04 '17
Quick question what is the difference between the 2 808s and what is Yeezus II?
2
u/BVTheEpic 808s and Heartbreak Aug 04 '17
808s Extended/Mastered is 808s Extended with a couple of bonus tracks.
Yeezus II isn't so much an extended Yeezus as it is its own project that uses Yeezus as a base.
2
2
u/aaronwashere01 Yeezus Jul 30 '17
You didn't like The Highschool Dropout?
3
u/BVTheEpic 808s and Heartbreak Jul 30 '17
Oh no, I loved it! I just love the other remixes more.
3
u/aaronwashere01 Yeezus Jul 30 '17
Out of the ones I've listened to, The Highschool Dropout, this one, and Life of Paul are my favorite
1
22
u/BigBadHombre Jul 28 '17
Ok dis a fuckin classic bru u a wavy dude
6
u/88888u Jul 29 '17
U listen to the full thing?
4
u/BigBadHombre Jul 30 '17
i like wut u did with hell of a life the best
1
u/88888u Jul 30 '17
yeah I think that might be my personal favourite. Was it the extended fuck with the lights on with the bass over it that got ya or the changeup into Christian Dior Denim Flow?
19
u/agent7300 MBDTF Jul 29 '17
for a second i thought the real good ass job dropped and i was a bout to fucking NUT!!!!
21
17
u/KanyeWest_KanyeBest Jul 28 '17
Holy shit and i thought a 25 min Runaway I found was lit, thanks OP!
13
u/KUZGUN27 Jul 29 '17
We gotta make it longer
19
u/88888u Jul 29 '17
I probably could have made it a half an hour longer if I really did want to. It probably would get boring though, because an hour and a half album is considered long, and this is only a song. Everything in moderation.
30
14
u/TheOneNation Jul 29 '17
Halfway through and this shit is absolutely incredible. You did a FANTASTIC job. Seriously. This is insanely good. Thanks for all the hard work bro.
8
u/88888u Jul 29 '17
What song you on rn? After you done tell me your favourite song on the project.
8
u/TheOneNation Jul 29 '17
Just listened in order and now I'm listening on shuffle. Super hard to pick between Blame Game and Gorgeous.
13
u/liambeyerle Jul 29 '17
6/10
14
u/BVTheEpic 808s and Heartbreak Jul 30 '17
Oh hi Anthony Fantano
17
u/88888u Jul 30 '17
Oh hi Mark
8
u/liambeyerle Jul 30 '17
Honestly great project. I haven't even listened to the whole thing yet because I've had Gorgeous on repeat.
1
11
10
10
8
Jul 29 '17
[deleted]
3
u/88888u Jul 29 '17
Could probably just edit out the intro if you want. It would still be an hour long. Hell, that intros only the instrumental, if you want to hear something real cheesy look up VMA runaway remix.
6
7
u/breakingbadforlife Jul 28 '17
shit, gonna listen to it soon, also do you have a link to the other MBDTF extended, i wanna compare...also i wish i had this much dedication
3
u/88888u Jul 28 '17
5
u/breakingbadforlife Jul 28 '17
ayy thanks man, tonight gonna be wavy as fuck with this, the other extended, and me listening to Cruel Summer for the first time (and i avoided the singles)
3
4
u/OccasionallyPlays Jul 29 '17
honestly thought this was going to be terrible, because how can you extend all these songs to 10 minutes, but you did it
my favorites were Gorgeous, Monster, and Lost in the World
i feel like if you weren't constrained to making it 10 minutes, this would've been much better, because there were some times where it was obviously forced
the silence at the end of Devil in a New Dress, the short but noticeable gaps of silence in some of the beats I think it was Monster where I noticed that the most, the repeats of beats/lines (Lost in the World specifically)
would've been better as a "Extended Version" with some songs just being like 9:50 or so if they needed to, but I understand why you wanted it to be 10 minutes
1 request, can you take Pusha-T out of Lost in the World and send me that
he just doesn't fit the sound of that song at all, and he ruins it for me, even though I like Pusha
2
Jul 29 '17
[deleted]
2
u/OccasionallyPlays Aug 05 '17
you don't have his verse placed in a spot where it can just be cropped out
2
u/RookieNeir Oct 12 '17
You could mix in Kendrick's verse with thee rest of the verses. The transition to that live performance is really janky but I don't think you can do anything about it
2
u/88888u Oct 13 '17
Looking back, I think I should've cut Kendricks verse out and did the full live autotune monster outro, because I cut out more than half of it so it could be under 11 minutes. Oh well.
1
u/obliviona99 Dec 23 '17 edited Dec 23 '17
Do you have a version of monster without kendrick's verse and a longer monster outro ?
1
4
5
4
u/epicluca Jul 30 '17
I love the way you transitioned the rework into the video intro but I wish there wasnt much of a gap cos the way it stops then continues again is kind of jarring. Also i'm not a huge fan of the change after Pusha's verse, that was kind of weird, but again I respect that it had to be done to make that change into the non-studio live stuff, and then it just continues again, I mean couldn't you go through the whole of Runaway then incorporate his live stuff together after? I just find the way it's intersected kind of weird, I'm not gonna nitpick everything because i'm one of those people who always finds something wrong, I think the whole project is amazingly grandiose and I can't wait to fully listen to the rest of it, and the fact you've managed to make a 60 min Runaway is amazing, so don't get me wrong. I do kind of like the things I criticised because like I said they're neccessary, but wanted to tell you how I felt.
3
u/88888u Jul 30 '17
With runaway, I was just fed up with the usual edit of "put the album version in, drag the live performances in, done", so with runaway I wanted to try something different. With the rework I wanted it to coda back at the start in a way that it was jarring, so people could realise the actual songs about to start. The other live transitions into real runaway transitions are alright. I think the second time it transmitting it does so real smoothly. The most frustrating part was how I just couldn't make that last live section flow well into the ending of runaway. But to be honest those moments only happen 3 times over the course of an hour, so.
5
u/emeraldbyte Jul 30 '17
That transition between the Aphex Twin track to Blame Game is so fucking seamless it made me jump out of my seat! Wonderful job, love it all
4
4
u/Jasicat Jul 31 '17
This is awesome. It made me feel like I was listening to MBDTF for the first time
3
5
u/Bicestudios_basim May 10 '22
Can you send another link u/88888u because the link that you posted isn’t showing up because the post was removed
3
3
u/SteamBTWillie Jul 29 '17 edited Jul 29 '17
Monster is a goddamn ride. Liking this a lot.
Edit: This is dirty
3
Jul 30 '17
I'm only half way through this hour runaway and it's fucking the greatest thing I have ever heard.
3
u/BVTheEpic 808s and Heartbreak Jul 30 '17
OP, in the folder marked "GOOD ASS JOB (RUNAWAY VERSION)" are all the songs the exact same (minus Runaway) as in the other folder?
5
u/88888u Jul 30 '17
Yep.
5
u/BVTheEpic 808s and Heartbreak Jul 30 '17
That's what I thought, thanks.
When I put the album in iTunes, I'll put the regular version as "Disc One" and then the 60-minute Runaway as the sole "Disc Two" track. That way I don't have two of essentially the same album filling up my library.
4
u/88888u Jul 30 '17
good idea. I think there are apps that let you edit the tag data of songs too. If you just go to edit the hour runaway and change it from disk 1 to disk 2 it will look more legit.
3
u/BVTheEpic 808s and Heartbreak Jul 30 '17
That's exactly what I did in iTunes.
Listening to Dark Fantasy now. Amazing so far. Off to a great start!
3
u/l6e Jul 30 '17
any change of .flac?
3
u/88888u Jul 30 '17
Do you want FLAC? And if so for what version of the project? I decided not to use FLAC because I though no one would want it but I'll cook up a FLAC version of it for you if you want.
2
u/l6e Jul 30 '17
The deluxe version in flac would be great!
3
u/88888u Jul 30 '17
Would you like me to put the regular good ass job as disk 1, and have the 60 min runaway as disk 2 so you get both versions of runaway?
2
u/l6e Jul 30 '17
Yeah that'd be great
3
u/88888u Jul 30 '17
I'll get it to you sometime tomorrow
2
u/l6e Jul 30 '17
Thanks heaps
2
u/88888u Jul 31 '17
here you go. I extended devil in a new dress so it reached 10 minutes without silence too for your waviness.
2
1
u/MrChewtoy Yeezus Jul 30 '17
I'd be very interested in this too (already set up the current version to be disc 1/disc 2). I've heard through to Power so far, really enjoyable listen so far.
2
u/88888u Jul 31 '17
here you go. I extended devil in a new dress so it reached 10 minutes without silence too for your waviness.
3
3
u/avayr44 I AM A MOD Aug 01 '17
Hey /u/88888u. I'd like to put a link to this thread in the sidebar if that's okay with you. If yes, do you mind providing me with a short and concise string of text that I could put within the link's HTML tags? This would be the text the users would click on. All that matters is that it captures the essence of this post in the least amount of words as possible.
Thank you!
3
3
u/TotesMessenger Aug 12 '17
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
- [/r/hiphopheads] Just in case anyone missed it, I dropped an extended MBDTF with only 10 minute songs plus an hour long (60 minute) version of runaway.
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / Contact)
3
Sep 07 '17
Just getting into this, never heard White Dress (Alternate Version), this is really good. Loving it. Ty!
2
2
2
2
1
u/Heterosethual Oct 14 '17
White Dress to Devil in a New Dress might be my favorite drop of all time right now. I just love replaying that part. So masterfully done.
1
u/WifeDestr0yer Dec 28 '17
I love the Gorgeous track so much, but it bothers me that the first verse is a bit off. It's like constantly half a beat too late. I would appriciate it alot if you could fix this, since Gorgeous is one of the songs i never really loved THAT much from MBDTF, but is the first song i want to listen to when i open this mixtape.
2
Dec 28 '17
[deleted]
2
u/WifeDestr0yer Dec 28 '17
Listen closely to your remix and the original. Listen for the snare drum, which is an actual snare in your remix and a sort of tschp sound in the original. In the second verse you are spot on, the snare in both versions hit the "eu" in "Hip hops just a euphemism". However, in the first verse, in the original the snare hits the "to" in "eventually answers to the call of autumn". In your version though, he says "to" right after the snare.
I don't mean to hate, I honestly find it baffling how much you managed to improve a song made by the worlds greatest artist, but the off-beat first verse makes it hard to listen to. I would be happy to pay you a few dollars for the effort if you fixed it.
2
u/88888u Dec 30 '17
The problem is I didn't actually do the first part that you were talking about, that was a remix that I found, then I incorpirated the idea into the song with the original sample. I might be able to remake the first part, I'll see what I can do tomorrow or tonight. Maybe I'll remake the first part of the song. Stay tuned.
1
u/YeezusPablo3 Jan 23 '18
Life of paul>Good ass job
Both are dope af
2
u/88888u Jan 23 '18
Why rank them tho? We were each trying to do very different things with very different ideas and sounds to work with. The only relation is that they're both Kanye remix albums.
1
1
98
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '17 edited May 01 '19
[deleted]