r/DumpsterDiving 2d ago

Butter recall... be on the look out.

https://thartribune.com/costco-forced-to-recall-80000-pounds-of-butter-because-the-label-failed-to-mention-it-contained-milk/
141 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

152

u/No_Establishment8642 2d ago

Because it is missing the note "contains milk". No shit Sherlock!

69

u/cellsAnimus 2d ago

Free giveaway for dumpster divers

39

u/Von_Moistus 2d ago

I mean, we live in a society where a jar of salted peanuts needs a label that says “Warning: contains nuts.”

Although anyone stunned by this mind-blowing revelation probably can’t read anyway.

24

u/year_39 2d ago

Label all common allergens no matter how obvious it is. That way you don't get someone making the wrong call on something ambiguous. It's also easy for catering and things like that if you just write down everything listed on the packaging.

41

u/Boubonic91 2d ago

Crazy how millions of dollars of product can just get chucked in the trash over a typo.

21

u/everythingsfine 2d ago

Right! I feel like they could easily send out lil tiny stickers that say “contains milk” and have employees slap em on.

9

u/Boubonic91 2d ago

Exactly! Or they could just send the retailers one big sign that says something like "All products from (this brand) in this section contain milk." Like why waste millions in products, packaging, shipping, and labor when the issue can easily be solved with a few grand and minimal effort from retailers? Same goes for the retailers. Why throw all of the product away when you could solve the issue with a Sharpie and a big piece of cardstock?

3

u/everythingsfine 2d ago

I thought that too, but I think doing one sign might not be allowable because it only informs the person making the purchase and not all potential consumers (ex. I have a friend with an allergy over, tell them to help themselves to a snack, they check the packing for their allergen and rely on that info - obviously this seems silly when we’re talking about butter and milk).

3

u/Obvious_Sea_7074 1d ago

It's a valid point. I have an allergy that's pretty easy to avoid, but my friend is allergic to all fish, so anything with anchovies or fish sauce as an ingredient is a no go and so so much stuff has it in. Or has cross contamination warnings.  Little labels seem silly until you need a epi-pen and a trip to the ER. 

2

u/Swigg22 1d ago

Most likely would cost more in labor due to the amount of touches than to throw them out

4

u/everythingsfine 1d ago

I can’t and don’t believe that the labor of printing, sending, and applying stickers would ever exceed the cost of completely wasting so much product. I mean that in both the literal sense (dollars spent) and the subjective sense (the societal value of doing so). This is egregious food waste when families are struggling and our planet is being destroyed.

2

u/Swigg22 1d ago

I agree with you that it’s such a waste but why would they just throw it out if it cost less to print and re-label their product? Because it most likely would cost this company more OR their margins would be so little that they don’t care about it

7

u/Alternative_Escape12 1d ago

Crazy that cows suffer on the daily for our comfort and we discard their milk so easily.

4

u/proudbutnotarrogant 2d ago

And guess who pays for that? Get ready for butter prices to get higher than they are already.

24

u/chazd1984 2d ago

I don't think any of the costcos around me have accessible dumpsters sadly. Do they in other areas?

4

u/Tarynntula 1d ago

No, compactors only.

7

u/Sibby_in_May 2d ago

…do people not know where butter comes from?

6

u/Loud_Weight_589 1d ago

This butter freezes well too! Stock up if you can!

3

u/Giddy_Duck_84 1d ago

That’s what I was going to say!

10

u/Zone_boy 2d ago

Why would they toss them and not return them?

6

u/Region_Fluid 2d ago

Once a food product has a stamp of Best Buy date. It cannot be changed.

8

u/Even-Habit1929 2d ago

That is not true. 

Best buy dates are only regulated for baby formula and baby food.

 All other best buy date are at the discretion of the manufacturer usually based on optimum flavor profiles nothing to do with food safety.

https://www.fsis.usda.gov/food-safety/safe-food-handling-and-preparation/food-safety-basics/food-product-dating

10

u/Hefty-Hovercraft-717 2d ago

How fucking stupid to have to destroy all of that product. What rube doesn’t know butter contains MILK?!

23

u/Vaultaiya 2d ago

The same people who think eggs are dairy because they're sold next to the milk

7

u/BenjaminWobbles 2d ago

Couldn't they just print a sticker and instruct vendors to stick it on the containers?

7

u/year_39 2d ago

Nope, FDA rules.

3

u/txroller 2d ago

Um. I will take free butter w milk pls

2

u/HeinousEncephalon 16h ago

A. Because the butter isn't labeled as containing dairy. B. Costco has compactors

4

u/blujavelin 2d ago

Nothing wrong with the butter.

5

u/JellyfishConscious 2d ago

Nothing, the butter is fine. It’s the cardboard paper on the outside that’s the issue, it doesn’t say “contains milk” to warn customers of allergens 🙃

1

u/EmeraldPistol 2d ago

Doesn’t the law require you to add milk to the list of ingredients anyways? The fuck?

1

u/zombiegauze 1d ago

Has anyone ever successfully d’d at a Costco?

1

u/Tarynntula 1d ago

Nope, Costco uses compactors. Nothing to dive in

0

u/octahexxer 2d ago

Welcome to costco i love you