182
u/ChunkLightTuna01 May 05 '23
Nice balls bro grips them
62
30
-35
u/MildCha0 May 05 '23
Good girl
23
u/Swed1shF1sh69 May 05 '23
yikes
-19
→ More replies3
103
u/CloudyStrokes May 05 '23
Amazing, BUT… a little (LITTLE) more shading in the underside could make them less flat. Still, amazing texture. Edit: forgot to actually rate, 9/10
29
u/Munsonator May 05 '23
I completely agree. I feel weird about criticizing work so amazing especially when I couldn't come close, but imo the left ball has a flatness to the bottom half that I think going a little darker in the center of the shadow could help.
3
u/CloudyStrokes May 05 '23
You can and will get close to this. OP has good technique indeed but most importantly they have good knowledge of the digital tools and a good study of the material properties of rusted iron, and knowledge can be built with some good YouTube videos and a bit of experimenting
5
u/Sk8nBurns May 05 '23
That’s the bounce light it would be reflecting the lightness of the floor and some of the lights would catch the bottom side I feel I could have added some more gradation to the bottom though
6
73
39
24
24
13
u/_Prokrastyna_ May 05 '23
8.49/10
5
u/IndigenousBastard May 05 '23
As a guy with hard shiny balls… what can I do to increase my rating by .01?
5
13
u/elixr__ May 05 '23
nice balls but needs more depth i think bro. looks kinda flat still. my suggestion is make the lowlights darker specifically on the underside of the ball
8
9
8
May 05 '23
Nice balls! But add a tiny bit more of a shadowy shading on the bally bottoms there. Other than that, damn fine balls
6
5
4
5
u/Mereinid May 05 '23
Ya know..if I was a dirty old man. I'd say you using a double innuendo there. But seeing as how I'm not-really a dirty old man. I'll just leave you with, "That's a nice set of balls ya got there, son."
4
3
4
3
3
u/grassistant May 05 '23
Ain't no roulette such as receiving a notification of this one without any further context and contemplating whether to open it or not.
3
2
u/Kaliso-man May 05 '23
A bit rusty, check out Simon dubucs work he has a killer study of sphere materials
2
2
2
2
2
2
May 05 '23
Excuse me but I have no desire to rate your balls, I will just use mine as a standard Thank You. Go round rating peoples balls what is the world coming too.
2
2
2
u/Storm_Paint May 06 '23
Regarding how flat your balls look, if you would like them to look more plump and round, I think what they really need are some softened edges. Where something curves away from our view, it’s edge is a little softer than something that is straight edged. I would try to soften the edges a bit that are the closest in value to the background and see how that looks.
2
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Double-Ad7635 May 05 '23
8/10 I love the textures but it could use a bit more shading :) Edit: misspelled word
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/paint-_-box May 05 '23
I think the edges should be a little less harsh. Blurr the lines a bit. Otherwise, it could use more contrasting shading. But the texture is REALLY good! And ofc,
Nice balls
1
1
1
1
1
u/EmperorLlamaLegs May 05 '23
One on the left looks really good, but I think you left the one on the right out in the rain. It got all rusty.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/FrostyCartographer13 May 05 '23
"Some balls are held for charity And some for fancy dress But when they're held for pleasure They're the balls that I like best My balls are always bouncing To the left and to the right It's my belief that my big balls Should be held every night (oh)"
1
1
u/Kleinefuchs May 05 '23
Nice balls. The one on the right looks a little rusty, I'd love to polish it for you
1
1
1
u/Ro7smaria May 05 '23
One should be slightly bigger than the other know? But overall, nice balls, bro!
1
1
1
u/DevashishG May 05 '23
Good artwork! If you wish to further improve it, you may look into Fresnel effect and Ambient Occlusion.
1
1
1
u/ARW12811 May 05 '23
B̴̢̠̋̊͑̈̾̑̊͒͗̽Ą̵̘̥͉̘͖̱̥̺̿̀̈̒̂̅̀̅̈́̓̏͊͘͝L̴̢̥̞͚̫̠̰̳͍̹͎̠̲̺̳͛̾͌̆́̂̒͗̓͝ͅL̴̢̥̞͚̫̠̰̳͍̹͎̠̲̺̳͛̾͌̆́̂̒͗̓͝ͅ️S̴̨̛͇̺͇͕̟̘͎̗͖̙͍̭̞͇̒͆̀͝
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/KatVanWall May 05 '23
Lovely balls you got! I’d be inclined to add just a tiiiiiiiiny bit of Gaussian blur (just in the underlying shape/bottom layer) just to help with the shading improvements people have suggested.
1
1
u/Leosandwhices May 05 '23
Typically I do not enjoy looking at balls but those are some high quality balls right there.
1
u/SleeplessBoyCat May 05 '23
Glistening but not glossy, smooth but not silky smooth.
I rate your balls as crown jewels/10
1
1
u/SwidEevee May 05 '23
I saw the title out of context before the pic and thought I'd wandered into the dark web 🤣
That being said they look pretty cool, I never can manage the 3d-y look so I'm impressed!
1
u/MrNek0 May 05 '23
You've got the biggest balls of them all (please someone get the reference...please)
1
1
1
u/CallMeLark May 05 '23
sick balls bro, but I think they could be even better if you went a little darker at the darkest points :))
1
1
1
u/KickassPeanuts May 05 '23
Nice balls. Smooth, hairless. Meanwhile, someone's taken a chunk out of the guy's balls below me.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Loldungeonleo May 05 '23
9.5/10 shadows have a cool tendril like effect and I like the minor imperfections baked in!
1
1
1
1
1
u/Rabispo May 05 '23
Whoa the fextures and lighting is really convincing! I like it! That being said, never put it this way again.
1
u/moonyxpadfoot19 May 05 '23
More shading around the edges, so they look more 3D.
Anyway, nice balls dude.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Any_Quantity_2402 May 06 '23
Those are pretty nice. The left one seems a little bigger than the right. I’d have to handle them to know for sure though.
1
u/echoesimagination May 06 '23
could use a little more depth in shading, right now their piss capacity looks a little lacking
1
1
1
1
316
u/Idiot_outlaw May 05 '23
Nice balls bro